Everyone is a feminist until a woman makes a mistake — our culture’s hunger to tear women down

Recently, Justin Baldoni dropped his counterclaim against Blake Lively because his stance that she was defaming him for accusing him of workplace sexual harassment was deemed not viable. While it’s a win for Lively and sets her up well for their March 2026 trial, does it really matter?

No matter the verdict of that trial, her public reputation is ruined — Baldoni’s team ran a pretty successful smear campaign against her. The team allegedly paid for bots on apps like X who repeatedly bashed Lively and pushed Baldoni as our Feminist King. They also brought up old and new negative stories, created fake rumors and ran past out-of-context clips where she comes across as mean — the worst trait a woman can possess.

Emma Clement

What is happening here is more than just vapid celebrity drama. It’s an example of the prevalence of manufactured online hate campaigns against women that everyone indirectly or directly participates in.

As a society, we go through cycles of choosing a woman whom we believe deserves to be punished. Maybe she reminds you of the girl who bullied you when you were young or the first girl who rejected you romantically. Perhaps we don’t like the way she smiles, or she just seems like a liar. Maybe she represents everything you are morally against.

We will pick apart every flaw of hers and turn all of her actions into indefensible crimes until we deem her rightly punished, then we choose the next woman to set our vitriol on.

Sometimes we do this to uplift other women — think of Hailey Bieber and Selena Gomez. Other times it may serve our need to tear a woman down for not being a “girls’ girl,” a term that is just another way for us to attack a woman for not behaving the way we want her to behave.  

 Through these teardown attempts, we hold up the old idea that there are only good and bad women, reinforcing our expectations for women to be perfect. This leads to women being pitted against each other even when there is no tension between them.

These types of smear campaigns are mostly prevalent when they serve the man in a woman’s life.

There is the case of John Lennon’s wife and artist Yoko Ono, who has been blamed for ruining Lennon and breaking up The Beatles, despite co-writing some of his biggest hits. Independent of Ono, the interpersonal relationships among the members ultimately imploded, which led to the band’s breakup. And yet Ono has been vilified and become a laughing stock in popular culture. 

Then there’s musician and widow of Kurt Cobain, Courtney Love, who society ruthlessly blamed and attacked after Cobain’s suicide. For over 30 years following his death, conspiracy theories, books and TV specials all point to Love’s involvement in his death and ignore his long battle with drug abuse, depression and difficulties handling his fame.

There is also Meghan Markle, who was considered responsible for ruining her husband, Prince Harry, and the Royal Family, which, oh well. Of course, race played a large part in the vitriol from the British public, and her being an American and a divorcee didn’t help either, but Markle didn’t do any wrongdoing besides rub some people the wrong way. 

These types of smear campaigns reached their apex in 2022 with the Amber Heard v. Johnny Depp defamation trial, where Depp sued Heard for defamation for a 2018 op-ed she co-wrote with the ACLU for The Washington Post. 

In the op-ed, Heard refers to herself as a “public figure representing domestic abuse,” and the article served as a plea for Congress to reauthorize the Violence Against Women Act, which was set to expire.

Heard did not mention Depp by name, but Depp saw it as the closest reason to claim that not only was the article defamatory, but also that he never laid a hand on her, despite mounds of evidence that he did so many times. 

The majority of social media users took his side, and Heard became the target of a global smear campaign that further pushed the claims Depp’s team created.

Truly, there has never been a more successful misinformation campaign than this one, and it’s pointless to go down the long list disproving all of Depp’s team’s claims.

These assertions persuaded the public to believe all of Heard’s evidence was an elaborate hoax. Rather than believing that an older man with a history of substance abuse, anger issues and alleged physical assault, dating back to when Heard was a toddler, had hit his wife, the public turned on Heard instead.

We praise and respect men as geniuses professionally, but when it comes to their personal lives, they are infantilised boys with no bodily autonomy. They get no blame for any action because, well, a woman made them do it. 

Depp laid his eyes on a young new actress and started sexually and physically abusing her when he was high or drunk. After several years of this, she started fighting back, blaming herself for their fights and staying due to his constant apologies and love bombing.

The popular narrative became that his career ended or slowed because of Heard’s article, rather than him aging out of the roles that made him famous or being a known liability on sets.  

Many of these targeted women are not perfect — some are far from it — but the way they are harassed is proportionally worse compared to how we shame a man.

 Men are allowed nuance — women aren’t. 

We set such high standards for women to follow that when they make a mistake, we perceive it as worse than what it actually is.

The tides are slowly shifting with women who have been hated in the past, such as Britney Spears, Monica Lewinsky and Janet Jackson.

With today’s lens, we can give them grace and see how they were wrongly treated. But despite this progress, we continue to use harassment tactics that have become worse with the rise of social media.

Unfortunately, it’s easy to make money off of misogyny. Hundreds of social media posts repeat the same derogatory commentary used to cruelly put women down. 

An example would be the thousands of people who made TikToks on Amber Heard’s rape testimony. Whether it be reenacting it, making fun of it or grossly sexualizing it, people took her story and used it to gain traction on TikTok.

A similar situation happened with Blake Lively when she came forward with the alleged sexual harassment she faced. Everyone jumped on the trend just because it was the popular consensus at the time.

Lively will not be the last woman at the center of a mass hate campaign. She and countless others serve as reminders that our culture is conditioned to quickly question, doubt and shame women. 

Change requires us to acknowledge that misogyny is an inherited part of our culture that must actively be resisted.  

Personal awareness is not a society-wide solution, but it makes us second-guess the next time we are about to contribute to a culture that is too eager to tear a woman down for the simplest mistakes. 

Until then, we will continue to see that society will hate women for just about anything. 



Read more here: https://dailyfreepress.com/11/30/14/216778/everyone-is-a-feminist-until-a-woman-makes-a-mistake-our-cultures-hunger-to-tear-women-down/
Copyright 2026