Editorial: Protect student journalism

 

On Oct. 14, 2025, the Director of Student Media at the University of Indiana (UI), Jim Rodenbush, was fired. This occurred one day after Rodenbush refused to comply with the media school’s orders not to print any news in The Indiana Daily Student’s (IDS) upcoming print edition. Following this, on Oct. 15, UI Media School Dean David Tolchinsky sent an order to IDS leadership saying that all print will be fully cut.

IU is a public institution. Public universities are required to uphold values under the U.S. Constitution regarding freedom of speech. Student media is crucial for providing a public forum for campus discussions, holding administration accountable and offering students real-world journalism experience.

The right to free press is a cornerstone of democracy that all personal freedoms depend upon. “Telling us what we can and cannot print is unlawful censorship, established by legal precedent surrounding speech law on public college campuses,” the IDS said.

If we cannot defend the First Amendment rights of student journalists, a new generation of reporters will rise surrounded by an atmosphere of fear and limitation. We must arm students with the tools to resist censorship to forge a future media landscape that wields the powers of accountability.

A national trend

On the same day that Tolchinsky cut funding for all print at UI, dozens of reporters turned in their media badges. Journalists walked out of the Pentagon after refusing to agree to reporting restrictions set by Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. According to the Trump administration, these restrictions were in an effort to “regulate a very disruptive press.”

Hegseth’s rules penalize journalists for routine news-gathering activities, banning inquiry about information that has not been explicitly approved for release.

AP News reported that, before implementing these restrictions, Hegeseth already “systematically choked off the flow of information.” He banned reporters from many areas throughout the Pentagon and held only two formal press briefings in the past ten months.

The American people are entitled to information regarding how the U.S. spends their tax dollars and how the country is run.

Despite insistent claims to be the “most transparent administration in history,” the Trump Administration has curated an environment where withholding public information is standard practice.

The administration is facing litigation from Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW). The litigation argues against what they call the “tearing up, disposal and removal of highest-level documentation.”

Trump has called the press “disruptive in terms of world peace.”

Normalizing the withholding of public information benefits Trump’s continual efforts to stop the release of the Epstein files, defund public media and control personal data.

The backlash 

In November 2024, the IDS printed a front-page spread with a caricature of Trump surrounded by critical quotes.

Indiana Governor Micah Beckwith responded, saying, “This type of elitist leftist propaganda needs to stop, or we will be happy to stop it for them.”

A March 2016 survey of college and university media advisers affiliated with the College Media Association revealed that over three years, more than twenty media advisers reported suffering some degree of administrative pressure to control, edit or censor student journalistic content.

When student writers do not agree with university policy, they are stuck between a rock and a hard place. Student media is highly dependent on financial support from its respective universities.  Supervisors and student writers are stuck with limited options on how to navigate developing pressure.

Like the University of Utah’s Daily Utah Chronicle, The Indiana Daily Student is an independent, student-run newspaper. Universities shouldn’t force reporters to argue for certain programs or ideologies. The U must stand as a protector of journalistic dignity in the face of rising censorship.

Although this case study at IDS is incredibly recent, limitations of student voices have been prevalent throughout U.S. history.

Why student journalism?

Student journalism is an exceptionally rare type of media work that fosters curiosity, self-development and the protection of American democracy.

Democracy requires its citizens to be involved and aware of decisions made by the federal and state governments. Being a journalist helps students to practice skills of critical thinking and analysis. It allows them to be aware of current events and spread that information to their peers.

Student bodies benefit from receiving news in a way that is easier to understand and directly applicable to their lives. The protection of uncensored student media grows both media literacy and activity within the democratic system.

Along with the plethora of student benefits, student journalism benefits the people. More than 25 million Americans received their news from student journalists in the 2023-24 school year. Americans need student journalism to receive timely local news.  An attack on student journalism is an attack on student liberty and voice.

Academic institutions were once the breeding ground for independent thought and the conjuring of new ideas. However, growing censorship across the country risks freedom of expression and speech. The U must stand as a symbol for the protection of independent thought, critical thinking and tolerance for all perspectives.

Students must recognize the severity of censorship on campus media and act in defense of democracy. Student journalism is the cornerstone of democracy. We cannot allow further censorship.

 

The Daily Utah Chronicle Editorial Board is a group of senior opinion journalists who rely on research and debate to write staff editorials. Editorials represent the majority view of the editorial board and are written separately from the newsroom. The Fall 2025 Editorial Board members are Morgan Champine, Elizabeth Griffee, Emma Thompson and Peakalika Ichimura.

The post Editorial: Protect student journalism appeared first on The Daily Utah Chronicle.

Read more here: https://dailyutahchronicle.com/2025/11/21/editorial-protect-student-journalism/
Copyright 2026