Opinion: Utah’s Polite Culture Impacts Individuality

 

Utah has a notable reputation for modesty and pleasantries. These values are deeply rooted in the state’s religious origins, pushing social norms embedded by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints’ teachings. This includes teachings such as the following excerpt “The spirit of contention is not of me, but is of the devil.” This teaching promotes avoiding conflict and contention. There is undoubtedly no incorrect aspect of teachings such as this, especially out of its provided context. However, it is important to note how such ideas impact Utah’s culture.

There must be a distinction between courteous expression and suppression of individuality. This idea stretches even beyond the church’s bounds as it is reinforced both in LDS and non-LDS environments. Overall, Utah has ranked as one of the most agreeable states culturally, with norms typically steering away from individuality. This cultural pull leads some to conform, stay silent or avoid expressing differing viewpoints, even if done respectfully.

The social norm has become quite regimented in uniform attitudes and forms of expression. In particular, how people disagree or express themselves, whether verbally or visually. These established norms in Utah have fostered strong community standards and a general sense of a cultural safety net. Meaning, if you follow the mindset that disagreeing must be done passively, then you are socially protected. In turn, this has been translated into what politeness looks like. But this polite mindset has shaped a larger culture where conformity is expected and outliers are quietly discouraged. 

It’s important to distinguish between genuine courtesy and the suppression of individuality. The line between being respectful and being repressive has grown increasingly blurred. As a result, the social norms in Utah have become overly regimented. This regimen includes the unspoken expectations about how people must behave, speak and feel. Therefore, politeness has become less about kindness and more about maintaining a specific image. These expectations leave little to no room for raw emotion, creative expression or open dialogue.

We need open dissent

Open dissent, the public expression of disagreement, is not a threat to our community. In a well-rounded society, disagreement allows us to refine ideas, foster fairness and grow beyond rigid ideologies. When sameness is the norm, critical thinking is replaced by silent compliance. This replacement is harmful since silent compliance often turns into deep-rooted resentment amongst peers. In Utah, social cohesion is prized, and discomfort is often avoided. Dissent is sometimes mistaken for disrespect. But challenging this sameness must not be considered inherently rude. Silent compliance does not make a community stronger. We need to hold space for disagreement and just raw reactions to real emotions. 

In contrast, many other U.S. regions, such as the East Coast or parts of the Pacific Northwest, tend to embrace open dissent as a sign of engagement rather than disruption. For example, cities like New York and Seattle are known for embracing public debate, emotional honesty and challenging authority as part of their social norms.

In these places, disagreement and individuality are not so quickly equated with hostility. Instead, these exchanges are typically associated with intellectual rigor or passion. This cultural difference fosters environments where people feel more comfortable expressing unique perspectives. When dissent is welcomed rather than silenced, it not only broadens collective understanding but also strengthens community bonds through authenticity and mutual respect.

Encourage authentic expression at the U

We must encourage authentic expression at the University of Utah. Socially, students must hold space for others to feel empowered to speak with honesty, creativity and conviction. Academically, students are expected to think critically, challenge norms and develop their voices. Which is proving to be difficult in a culture that prizes politeness over authenticity.

The aforementioned influence of LDS beliefs is not absent from classrooms. The subtle pressure to conform to dominant beliefs occurs whether in classrooms, student groups or casual conversations. Expressing a controversial opinion, questioning authority or simply showing emotion that doesn’t fit the pleasant mold is taboo.

When students are free to voice unpopular ideas, ask hard questions or express emotional truth, campus becomes a space of genuine learning. If we want to prepare students for the “real world,” they must be able to grow beyond being agreeable. This includes creating classrooms where disagreement isn’t shut down, clubs where difference is welcomed and conversations where authentic expression is safe.

True community doesn’t come from everyone thinking or acting the same. Instead, it must come from allowing space for discomfort, challenge and diverse voices. Honest and individual expression is what makes life meaningful.  It’s what pushes culture forward.

Individuality starts when we all choose to speak up when it may otherwise seem uncomfortable to do so.

 

s.akin@dailyutahchronicle.com

@shannonakinwrites.bsky.social‬

The post Opinion: Utah’s Polite Culture Impacts Individuality first appeared on The Daily Utah Chronicle.

Read more here: https://dailyutahchronicle.com/2025/08/29/opinion-utahs-polite-culture-impacts-individuality/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=opinion-utahs-polite-culture-impacts-individuality
Copyright 2026