Utah Attorney General Derek Brown is leading a nationwide effort to impose more restrictions on illegal online gambling. A bipartisan coalition he co-led sent a letter to the Department of Justice earlier this month, warning that many of these platforms expose Americans to “fraudulent schemes and highly addictive gambling.”
Utah’s legislature has upheld an anti-gambling stance since before statehood, making it the most restrictive state in the nation for gambling.
History of gambling in Utah
As Utah’s government began to take shape, leaders of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS) established strict rules against gambling, betting and con games.
“Let a judge decree that … a gambling saloon shall be established in our city, and we will give him the privilege to get out of the city as quickly as he can,” Brigham Young stated in an 1866 sermon.
A 1992 petition drive to legalize pari-mutuel betting failed, with supporters blaming the LDS Church, which had issued a statement saying, “Experience has clearly shown gambling to be harmful to the human spirit.”
Marianne McKnight, a history professor and senior associate dean for faculty affairs at Salt Lake Community College, explained the Church’s reaffirmation of its opposition to gambling in the late 20th century.
“[Religious leaders] reaffirmed the LDS Church’s opposition to gambling by saying it was hurtful to families, hurtful to individuals and hurtful to the morality of the communities,” McKnight said. “The LDS Church got into it by making statements saying that this was a public as well as a private moral issue. They felt that because it was a moral issue that the Church could make a statement.”
Concerns and criticisms
The LDS Church holds considerable influence in Utah politics, with members making up a majority of state legislature positions.
“An overwhelming contributor to the current attitude concerning gaming in Utah is rooted in the attitude of the members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints,” Jack Butterfield wrote in his 2013 dissertation, “This is the Place: Utah’s gaming history and current attitude.”
He discussed some of the Church’s concerns about gambling.
“Overall, from a sociological perspective, gambling does have some serious disadvantages that must be taken into consideration if deciding whether or not to legalize gambling,” Butterfield wrote. “However, like addicts from other vices such as alcohol, it is safe to assume that those who desire will go to great lengths to satisfy the need regardless if it is not readily available.”
McKnight elaborated on the state’s reservations, highlighting potential financial factors.
“Another argument lawmakers make is that gambling is predatory in nature,” McKnight said. “What they mean by that is that it targets low-income individuals — people who are most in need of money are willing to take the greatest risk to make a lot.”
She also acknowledged an alternate perspective.
“I would say the foremost argument for legalizing a lottery or some other forms of gambling would be to raise revenue for the state,” McKnight said. “That then could unburden people who are being taxed.”
According to the attorneys general coalition’s letter, recent estimates show the volume of illegal online gaming exceeds $400 billion annually, leading to more than $4 billion in lost tax revenue for state governments.
Legality and presence in Utah
The Utah legislature doubled down on its position in 2012, tackling online gambling in House Bill 108.
The bill states that a person is guilty of gambling — a class B misdemeanor — if a person:
- participates in gambling, including any Internet or online gambling;
- knowingly permits any gambling to be played, conducted, or dealt upon or in any real or personal property owned, rented, or under the control of the actor, whether in whole or in part; or
- knowingly allows the use of any video gaming device that is:
- in any business establishment or public place; and
- accessible for use by any person within the establishment or public place.
McKnight suggested that the recent tightening of Utah’s laws may be driven by repeat offenders.
“As you know, in any state where it’s illegal, it doesn’t mean people aren’t violating the law,” McKnight said. “It happens all the time. I mean, it’s ubiquitous, and yet it’s as soon as if it’s found out, then there could be repercussions.”
t.govitviwat@dailyutahchronicle.com
The post Inside Utah Gambling first appeared on The Daily Utah Chronicle.