Winners and Losers of the MLB Trade Deadline

 

Despite only three games being in action, July 31 was one of the most entertaining days of the MLB season.

In the 31 hours leading up to the trade deadline, a total of 50 trades took place between major league GMs. Prospects, proven MLB-level talent and cash considerations were flying left and right throughout what may go down as the wildest trade deadline ever.

In Major League Baseball, teams generally fall under one of two categories at the deadline: buyers or sellers. The decision to fall under the threshold of these categories is made by general managers, who are responsible for determining what is best for the future of their baseball team. 

This year was unusual, however, as there was a significant rise in what we’ll call “middlers.” These teams didn’t lean one way or another when it came to the future direction of their franchises. They stood pat, hoping the trajectory of their seasons would change for the better. This strategy is uncommon, as it can create an endless cycle of indecision amongst players, coaches and managers. 

Teams that fall under this umbrella include the post-Devers trade San Francisco Giants, Los Angeles Angels and Boston Red Sox. In the short sample size since the start of August, the Giants and Angels have struggled, while the Red Sox have caught fire. This rarely seen strategy has its highs and lows, and while it’s far too early to tell, it doesn’t seem to be a needle-mover for any of these organizations. 

Buyers

Throughout the MLB, there were a shockingly high number of teams that could be considered full buyers. This list of nine teams put all their chips on the table, hoping to win a World Series trophy in 2025. The reason there is a risk that comes with going all in is the near guarantee that it will hold a franchise back in the distant future. 

Trading away highly touted prospects was something these teams didn’t shy away from, so long as it meant filling holes to create a more complete playoff-ready roster. The list of full buyers at the 2025 deadline includes the Los Angeles Dodgers, Chicago Cubs, New York Yankees, New York Mets, Philadelphia Phillies, San Diego Padres, Toronto Blue Jays, Seattle Mariners and Houston Astros.

With all nine of these teams being in the top 11 of the current World Series odds, the 2025 champions will likely emerge from this list of full buyers. 

Sellers

A handful of teams dumped off their highly sought-after players in exchange for what they hope will become future success. Whether the start of the season didn’t go the way they expected, or talent emerged from their farm systems, these underwhelming teams had assets that the buyers wanted. 

A handful of clubs dumped the load of these players to the contenders, often in exchange for young players or prospects that could be built around in the future. While some sold more than others, the list of teams that went hard in this direction includes the Arizona Diamondbacks, Minnesota Twins, St. Louis Cardinals and Colorado Rockies.

While these teams have more or less given up on the 2025 season, look for them to bounce back in 2026 with reloaded talent.

Overall, an exciting trade deadline had Major League Baseball fans in a frenzy, as their favorite teams, in many cases, changed the trajectory of how the future will play out. 

 

j.leone@dailyutahchronicle.com

@johnleone5.bsky.social

The post Winners and Losers of the MLB Trade Deadline first appeared on The Daily Utah Chronicle.

Read more here: https://dailyutahchronicle.com/2025/08/13/winners-and-losers-of-the-mlb-trade-deadline/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=winners-and-losers-of-the-mlb-trade-deadline
Copyright 2026