An Open Letter to the Provost Search Committee and President Pestello

Originally Posted on The University News via UWIRE

Over the past two weeks students, faculty, administrators and staff have had an opportunity to meet virtually with the four finalists for the permanent Provost position at Saint Louis University. The committee considered over sixty applicants, selected a diverse pool of very qualified candidates, and now seeks feedback from the entire SLU community before making its hiring recommendations to President Pestello.

As a faculty member in the College of Arts & Sciences in my seventeenth year of service at SLU, as the first person of color hired onto the tenure track in my department, and as a member of SLU’s Committee on Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion, I view the appointment of the next Provost as a referendum on SLU’s commitment to diversity and inclusion. Of the four highly qualified finalists, three are better positioned to embody the leadership our university needs at this juncture in its history. By hiring one of these three candidates Saint Louis University would take a giant step toward diversifying its administrative ranks. This is an appeal beyond mere tokenism: there is more at stake in this decision than public relations. I am looking for a substantive change of direction that will signal to our faculty and students of color that SLU is taking concrete action to diversify our campus. That is why I urge the search committee and President Pestello to carefully consider three of the four finalists—Dr. Karen Riley, Dr. Eddy Rojas or Dr. Hugh Page.

I have known and worked with interim Provost Mike Lewis, who is the fourth candidate, over many years of service at SLU. We were both hired in 2004 and I consider Dr. Lewis a man of good character who has faithfully served this institution for many years. Alas, that’s the problem. Since 2013 Dr. Lewis has held a leadership position within the Provost’s office, first as Associate Provost, then Acting Provost, and now Interim Provost, and in all that time, despite his best intentions, relatively little progress has been made on matters of diversity, equity and inclusion. While Dr. Lewis served in these positions, SLU’s faculty of color have seen extremely qualified minority faculty passed over for department chair, interviewed but not hired for administrative positions, and generally excluded or marginalized within SLU’s decision-making infrastructure. This is not Dr. Lewis’s fault. But being so entrenched in existing university power structures makes it hard for me to believe that his appointment as permanent Provost will bring about desired change on matters of diversity.

Bold action is needed to recruit and retain highly qualified African American, Latinx and other minority faculty and staff. Embarrassingly for SLU, despite articulating its commitment to diversity and inclusion, the university has had a net loss in the number of African American faculty in the six years since the Clock Tower Accords. Sadly, the same lack of progress is evident in SLU’s efforts to recruit and retain students of color, especially African American and Latinx students. Looking ahead to the demographic drop—the prediction that the college-age population in the Midwest will drop by 5% in the mid-2020s—SLU administrators are panicked to the point of considering cutting faculty lines and closing programs in anticipation of this drop in enrollments. Yet in 2009, when I was asked by Dean Don Brennan of the College of Arts & Sciences to attend a conference funded by the Lilly Fellows Program on recruiting and retaining students of color, and submitted a report outlining a comprehensive strategy for making SLU a more welcoming environment for minority students, the report was forwarded to the Provost’s office, never to be seen again. The Latinx student population in four-year colleges and universities in the US doubled from 1996 to 2016 and shows no sign of slowing. Yet at SLU the number of Latinx students remains well under 10%, even though Hispanics now constitute the largest minority group, 18% of the US population, and Latino/as also represent 40% of the US Catholic population. The numbers are worse among African American students, who account for only 5.3% of the SLU student population despite the fact that 45.3% of the residents of St. Louis City and 18% of residents in the greater St. Louis metropolitan area are African American.

The search committee is to be commended for prioritizing diversity in their selection process and for having narrowed the field to four extremely well qualified candidates. All the candidates have impressive records in university administration, but only three of the candidates have a measurable track record of diversifying their faculty and student populations. Dr. Karen Riley created a partnership to bring students of color to the University of Denver that not only increased the chances a minority student will enroll in college, it also increased student success rates after enrollment by helping minority students prepare for college, providing opportunities to build skills that will contribute to their future success, and in helping them identify viable career options. During Dr. Eddy Rojas’s tenure at the University of Dayton as Dean of the School of Engineering, underrepresented undergraduate populations grew from 5% to 15%, and he appointed the first female Associate Dean in more than 20 years, as well as the first female department chair and the first female endowed chair in the school’s history. Dr. Hugh R. Page, Jr., currently Vice President and Associate Provost for Undergraduate Affairs at the University of Notre Dame, not only helped establish the Department of Africana Studies at Notre Dame, but has been part of three major strategic planning committees focused on diversity and inclusion, and for the past six years served on the leadership team in the Provost’s Office advancing the recruitment and retention of women and faculty of color at Notre Dame. These three candidates all have something else in common besides their diversity—they all come from universities that have created pipelines for promoting and training diverse faculty to move into administrative positions, so that these candidates now have the experience and expertise to serve as chief academic officer of a university. SLU does not have such a pipeline, and its leadership ranks are distinguished by an appalling lack of diversity in terms of gender, race and ethnicity.

I do not question interim Provost Lewis’s commitment to diversity and inclusion. As he wrote in his cover letter when applying for the Provost position, “Diversifying our student population is not merely a strategic enrollment and financial need—it is a moral imperative.” Unfortunately, Lewis is not an outsider looking in, but instead an integral member of the leadership and decision-making process that has not delivered on the promise of the Clock Tower Accords to change the culture of the university to become more welcoming and supportive of faculty and students of color. This culture has not only failed to systemically address its lack of diversity in terms of recruitment and retention, but also in terms of creating structures for promotion and advancement of its existing minority faculty. Again, no one’s sincerity or good intentions are in question. What I question is the depth of this candidate’s entanglements as part of SLU’s status quo that continues to pay lip service to diversity, equity and inclusion without demonstrable and quantifiable change.

Albert Einstein is credited with saying that the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again while expecting a different result. I am appealing to the Provost search committee and to President Pestello, with whom the decision ultimately rests, to select a candidate who has lived experiences that will bring fresh insights to the ongoing challenges at SLU. In a year that witnessed the nation’s deep racial, cultural and even theological divisions give rise to white nationalist violence, acts that have cast a glaring spotlight on structures of inequity that run deep throughout our society and institutions, Saint Louis University is confronted with the opportunity to install new leadership and hold all of us accountable to the mission that unites us. President Pestello, please do the right thing.

Read more here: https://unewsonline.com/2021/01/an-open-letter-to-the-provost-search-committee-and-president-pestello/
Copyright 2026 The University News