‘The Baby-Sitters Club’ is Netflix’s song of the summer 

‘The Baby-Sitters Club’ is Netflix’s song of the summer 

Babysitters Club

Netflix/Courtesy

Grade: 4.0/5.0

On July 3, Netflix released “The Baby-Sitters Club,” a TV adaptation of Ann Martin’s book series of the same name. With exceptional performances and sly humor, the Netflix series breathes new life into Martin’s treasured characters in a heartwarming and sincere adaptation as well as brings its classic source material into the 21st century. Though the show is not immune to some of the pitfalls that plague many modern teen-oriented shows, it effortlessly elicits smiles and laughter and offers a delightful viewing experience for both kids and adults alike. 

“The Baby-Sitters Club” follows the lives of five middle schoolers in Stoneybrook, Connecticut — Kristy (Sophie Grace), Mary Anne (Malia Baker), Claudia (Momona Tamada), Stacey (Shay Rudolph) and Dawn (Xochitl Gomez) — who form a club that provides the community with a roster of reliable and affordable babysitters. While managing their babysitting careers, the club members each deal with their own unique struggles to find their places in their families, in their schools and in their relationships with one another. 

Even for those who haven’t read the book series, the girls’ distinct character traits are recognizable from the moment we meet them. The credit for creating their rich personalities belongs only to Martin, but the show brings the characters to life by rooting every creative choice in the author’s original archetypes. During club meetings, the actors’ emotional reactions to one another are consistent and specific, betraying their characters’ insecurities and points of pride without them having to say a word.

Grace and Gomez, in particular, excel in their roles. As the club’s president and founder, Kristy’s leadership skills often keep the club together, but she shows a dark side whenever her authority is challenged. From the first episode, it’s clear that Kristy does not hesitate to speak her mind when she feels slighted, but the most fascinating details of her characterization come through in smaller moments. Grace’s control over her performance allows her to make clear exactly how Kristy feels about a given situation with little more than a furrowed brow or a slight facial twitch.

Likewise, Gomez shines as Dawn in the latter half of the series, which finishes with her brilliant turn as a camper-turned-revolutionary fighting against the unfair practices of a local summer camp. Dawn provides much of the comic relief in two drama-heavy episodes, with Gomez cementing her role as an indispensable cast member despite not joining the show until the fourth episode. Though the show occasionally adopts the perspective of the dismissive camp directors, Gomez — like Dawn — doesn’t compromise an inch in her earnestness, and the audience can’t help but take the kids more seriously than the adults.

Dawn’s camp revolution is one example of the commitment the show makes to taking its characters and their problems seriously. Though the girls deal with their problems maturely, their mistakes are characteristic of people their age. Nonetheless, the show legitimizes their struggles without simply grafting adult experiences onto teenage characters, reminding the adults in the audience how it felt to be in middle school — a time when angering a friend or disappointing a parent felt nothing short of apocalyptic. 

Like many other shows in its genre, “The Baby-Sitters Club” suffers from stunted writing at times. Many of the jokes and catchphrases aim to capture the way young people today talk to each other, but they end up sounding more like grown adults’ guesses as to how teenagers might talk based on their own childhoods and teen movies from the 1990s. Though this flaw is not as pervasive here as it is in other teen shows, such as those on the CW, when it does occur, it distracts from an otherwise exceptional viewing experience.

Still, “The Baby-Sitters Club” is a cheerful and lighthearted series guaranteed to put a smile on the face of anyone who watches it, whether child or adult. With its brilliant cast, engrossing plotlines and timely messaging, the show has something to offer for both longtime fans of the books and new converts. This summer, Stoneybrook is the place to be.

Contact Matthew DuMont at mdumont@dailycal.org.

The Daily Californian

Read more here: https://www.dailycal.org/2020/07/16/the-baby-sitters-club-is-netflixs-song-of-the-summer/
Copyright 2026