
“What is your favorite confession?”
Although people ask me this question all the time at social gatherings, I still have to close my eyes and mentally flip through all the confessions I’ve received in the past years.
Since I’m pretty invested in the quality of the page, I’m naturally biased toward the confessions that have received the most praise from the public. As a populist, I care about the public’s perspective on the content the page publishes. Sure, there are instances in which the public may seem untrustworthy, but when you look at, for example, the best-selling musical artists of all time, the list seems pretty solid. The Beatles are right there at the top where they probably belong. So some of my first picks for my favorite confession of all time are the ones I consider the most successful.
When I look at the confessions that got the most reactions ever, I see a truly outstanding selection. One is about losing one’s virginity with the Shrek soundtrack in the background, one is a wholesome thank you for a borrowed Scantron and one is a long and sad tale of failing one’s dying father. They cover the range of human emotions, each one got more than a thousand reactions, and taken together, they perfectly embody what Confessions is supposed to be. I’m proud of having selected each of them from the pool of submissions. But in the metric of reactions, one post stands above the rest.
The legendary League of Legends post garnered nearly 13,000 reactions, making it the most-reacted-to confession ever. The format is great: The paragraph starts with a clear thesis statement, then elaborates expertly. The author of the post describes moving in with their boyfriend only to find that he plays five hours of League per day, which culminates into the author’s immense frustration, and they go on to describe the consequences of that vividly. Each detail (“making it a 9v1”) is so perfectly placed. I think the poster comes across as just the right amount of righteously frustrated – enough to strike a chord with the audience but not enough to alienate any of them.
Through a share to the Subtle Asian Traits group, which has more than 1.7 million members, the League of Legends post was exposed to a much larger audience who related heavily to the post, despite most of them not being UC Berkeley students. I would say the post was good enough to go viral, and that’s what sets it apart.
But it’s not the only confession that’s gone viral. On two separate occasions, screenshots of confessions reached the front page of Reddit through being posted on popular subreddits: once on r/Trashy, and once on r/MurderedByWords, each time gaining about 70,000 upvotes. To me, those feats of virality are utterly astonishing and surreal, exceeding all the expectations that I have ever had for the Confessions page.
Interestingly, the two viral Reddit confessions have a few things in common. They both criticize a male romantic prospect in a shallow way, and they both prominently feature a comment from the original post containing a snappy takedown. Certainly, I admit the two posts went viral as much for these comments as they did for the posts themselves. Though really, that is not such a bad thing. In my mind, part of the appeal of a great confession is its ability to elicit a response, even if that response is extremely negative. The shallowness that these posts exhibit is as much of a human trait as the exasperation seen in the League post or the gratitude of the Scantron post. I think there is a perverse beauty in being able to see the kind of unfiltered ugly thoughts that only a confessions page can really offer. I like to say that the confessions that expose the dark and shameful parts of oneself are the ones that bear the most resemblance to the Catholic concept of confession, which is probably what confessions pages draw their original inspiration from.
Populist though I am, when I have to choose just one Confessions post as the greatest of all time, I don’t bind myself by sheer numbers. The numbers matter, sure, but sometimes, a confession makes you feel something really special. There is something to be said about brevity; a truly great post can tell a whole story in just a few characters. The League post’s exaggerated ranting is undeniably funny, and the almost comically shallow viral confessions perfectly ensnared the vindictive attention of Reddit.
But I prefer a post that gives us one shining expression of human emotion: no frills, no clickbait, no memes. And when it comes down to it, there’s just one post that finds that perfect combination of conciseness, genuineness and popularity. The first time a confession broke a thousand reactions was February 4, 2019, and I’ll never forget what it said because when I think about it, I know it’s still my favorite confession. “1553. I got into med school!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!”
Spencer Hill writes the Friday column on being a moderator of Overheard at UC Berkeley and Confessions from UC Berkeley. Contact him at opinion@dailycal.org.