Europe for The Europeans: The Case for NATO Reform

 U.S. Defense Secretary Jim Mattis addresses the press at NATO headquarters in Brussels on June 29, 2017

U.S. Defense Secretary Jim Mattis addresses the press at NATO headquarters in Brussels on June 29, 2017.

“NATO is obsolete.” When Donald Trump first voiced criticism of the Atlantic partnership, Washington’s foreign policy elites were quick to condemn the candidate’s calls for more equitable burden-sharing between the United States and Europe as further evidence of his foreign policy inexperience. Now, however, President Trump seems to have shifted course. “It’s no longer obsolete,” he declared last May, claiming to have single-handedly redirected the alliance’s focus towards counterterrorism. Two months later, he publicly affirmed his support for the mutual defense commitment enshrined in Article 5 of the NATO Charter. Problem solved? Not quite. For once, the erratic incumbent might have been onto something.

Barack Obama had already voiced his frustration with the alliance in 2015, saying, “Freeriders aggravate me.” His complaints echoed those of former Defense Secretaries Leon Panetta and Ashton Carter, as well as ex-president George W. Bush. The United States has repeatedly turned a blind eye to the chronic underpaying of its European friends. But today NATO has fulfilled its ostensible purpose. Not only did the alliance successfully deter any Soviet aggression in Europe during the Cold War; ultimately, it helped bring about the collapse of that “evil empire.” Thus, America’s continued military involvement in Europe may now be a source of conflict rather than stability.

For a long time, U.S. security commitments have allowed its European allies to freeride on American military protection. There is a kernel of truth in Trump’s hyperbolic complaint that “we have subsidized the armies of other countries.” Although the total budget of America’s European allies exceeds that of the United States, the latter accounts for roughly three quarters of NATO’s total military spending. This alarming discrepancy has only increased in recent years. Today, only four of the 27 other member states spend the requisite two percent of GDP on defense. Nor do European countries appear willing to help their American treaty partners in return. NATO’s European members have opposed U.S. engagement in Iraq and provided only perfunctory support for American efforts in Afghanistan.

American military presence in Europe seems to be a relic of the past rather than a necessity of the present. The bases that used to defend free Germany from communist control lie today at the center of an independent and united continent. While Vladimir Putin’s aggressive foreign policy has induced bouts of Russophobia among American elites, concerns about Russia’s military renaissance may be overstated. Putin seeks to increase Russian soft power in Eastern Europe, not to invade the European heartland. Moreover, the European Union possesses more than sufficient economic and military capabilities on its own to deter a potential Russian challenge. In 2010, European Union members collectively devoted $275 billion to their national militaries. Russia, four years later, was still spending a meager $70 billion.

In addition to being unnecessary, America’s leadership of NATO may be counterproductive. By emboldening reckless allies and menacing Russia, the United States has unwittingly promoted conflict rather than stability in Europe. Russia’s invasion of Georgia in 2008 was encouraged by the latter’s efforts to join the NATO alliance. As NATO threatened to subsume Ukraine under its control, Putin deemed it necessary to intervene in order to establish a buffer zone in the Donbass. From Russia’s perspective, the United States seems intent on doing away with the last vestiges of Russian pride and power. 16 years after the end of the Cold War, a potent alliance—led by Russia’s geopolitical arch adversary, and founded upon the basis of mutual hostility to its political predecessor—continues to expand into formerly Russian territory. Obama’s decision to deploy additional troops to reassure European allies thus likely exacerbated rather than alleviated tensions. Though both sides may only seek to preserve the status quo, mutual fear and ignorance about the other’s true intentions risk creating a dangerous spiral of violence.

Who had it right then, candidate or President Trump? In his quest for simplistic and marketable answers, the billionaire businessman is poised to neglect the nuances of American strategy. NATO is not obsolete, but it is also not sustainable in its current form: the current U.S. military presence in Europe is wasteful and destabilizing. While the United States can choose to remain in NATO, it should pass responsibility for Europe’s defense on to the Europeans. This could bring a number of unintended benefits. For one, it could finally compel the European Union to build its own army. Ironically, Trump’s erratic foreign policy, which has dramatically decreased member states’ trust in the United States, may thus strengthen European integration much more than Obama’s unwavering support for the union. Were the United States to withdraw its forces from Europe, the festering anti-Americanism that undermines U.S. legitimacy on the continent and weakens American business interests could also finally subside. Trump has come upon an uncomfortable truth: NATO needs to be made fit for the 21st century.

 

Image credit: U.S. Department of Defense/Air Force Staff Sergeant Jette Carr

Read more here: http://harvardpolitics.com/world/europe-for-the-europeans-the-case-for-nato-reform/
Copyright 2026