Op-Ed: Gorsuch and Resistance

Originally Posted on Whitman Wire via UWIRE

A few nights ago, amidst much pomp and circumstance, a blow was dealt to American democracy. Standing in the White House’s famed East Room Donald Trump informed the media of his choice to succeed Antonin Scalia as the ninth Justice of the Supreme Court, Judge Neil Gorsuch.

Our democracy does not suffer for this choice of jurist; by all appearances Gorsuch is an eloquent, deeply conservative Originalist in the mold of the man he would succeed. The damage to democracy was done in the 354-day interim since Scalia passed. In that time Senate Republicans broke from centuries of precedent and refused to even consider President Barack Obama’s nominee, Judge Merrick Garland. Garland’s virtues as a judge need not be extolled here. Suffice it to say: he is the among our nation’s best jurists and ignoring him was a Constitutional travesty.

That injustice reverberates not only in the Constitutional realm, but also in the everyday. My sisters now fear for their access to reproductive care. Members of the LGBTQ community fear the Court will prioritize religious rights over freedoms from discrimination. Victims of police violence fear that their civil rights will become little more than symbolic protections.

We on the Left must now confront an immensely difficult situation. Many in the Democratic Party and beyond already are calling for a quid pro quo. Block Gorsuch’s nomination as the Republicans did with Garland, they say. But as Ted Cruz quickly reminded the media, Senate Republicans are not above invoking the “nuclear option,” changing the nomination process rules to prevent a filibuster. In other words, Gorsuch will likely sit on the Court. So what should concerned Democrats do?

Some say to accept the nomination is to “normalize” Trump. That’s what Republicans want, they say, for us to sit back and let it happen. “Protest, every second of his administration.”

But why do we protest? To show solidarity with our oppressed brothers and sisters, no doubt. Also because Trump hates it, and fuck him. But protest is also the means to a vital political end in a representative democracy: it allows us to convey our support for a view in a politically and socially visible fashion. It tells our elected officials we care but more importantly it tells our fellow citizens that we care. In the end the tangible effects of protest come from reaching others and sparking in them some empathy or feeling of common cause.

Whose mind do we need to change? Certainly not the Pantsuit Nation, or Planned Parenthood Generation Action, or the American Constitutional Society. Their minds are made up in support of our concept of justice. We need to reach those who aren’t sure where they fall. The white middle class voter in Wisconsin who is really just worried about his kids living well and his Social Security check. The moderately conservative woman in Arizona. The twenty-something southerner who isn’t quite convinced of their parent’s views. They don’t live in our liberal echo-chamber and haven’t been subsumed by a conservative one either. They are Pennsylvania, Ohio, Wisconsin, Michigan. They are who the modern Democratic political machine has forgotten about.

Protest everything, they say. I disagree. The moment protest becomes the default reaction to anything Trump does is the moment protest loses its efficacy in consciousness raising. Let’s protest an immigration ban that stands on an embarrassingly shabby legal footing, contravenes fundamental American values, and has only tenuous support among many Republican lawmakers. Tell the above-mentioned moderate voter a story about Christian love for the meek, American acceptance of the tired and huddled masses, and ISIS’ support for the Muslim ban, and you might just sway their mind. When center-right lawmakers start hearing from their normally-quiet constituents on the immigration ban, when they feel pressure from the people they thought were “in the bag,” see how long the executive order will last.

Is Gorsuch worthy of such opposition? No. Trump would love for liberals to protest a solid conservative jurist’s nomination by a Republican president. It makes us look impetuous, like we will never be satisfied with anything Trump does. It makes us look like we can’t even take the basic functioning of democracy. His supporters, and more importantly, those folks still undecided about how to vote in 2018 or 2020, will disregard our protest as the default response.

This is not to suggest Liberals ought to forego any resistance work related to Gorsuch. And in Gorsuch’s predecessor we find surprising guidance on how to proceed. In writing his forceful dissents against extensions of constitutional rights, Justice Scalia argued that it was legislators and democracy, not the courts, that ought to guarantee access to abortion. While I would prefer the courts be closely engaged, we must now prepare to live in Scalia’s jurisprudential world. Where once we appealed to high-minded constitutional principle, we must now return to grassroots legislative advocacy. In short, we must talk to our fellow citizens. As our former President, Barack Obama, said in his farewell address, change in a democracy comes only to those willing to fight for it.

What odd bedfellows do Scalia and Obama make. But their words provide us a clear path forward. If abortion rights cases will be lost to the Supreme Court’s new conservative majority, then we must litigate in the court of public opinion. We must redraw electoral lines to guarantee fair representation. We must demand of our public officials the same commitment to protecting women’s rights that the Court affirmed in Roe and Casey. Most importantly, we must learn to reach out to those who think differently than us.

Protest is important. But for protest to retain the power it has had throughout the history of our democracy it must also be meaningful. The spontaneous demonstrations that broke out in airports across the country this past week were meaningful. What happened at Standing Rock was meaningful, and continues to be. But protesting a mainstream conservative appointed by a Republican president is not. If we don’t pick our battles, we may lose the war.

Read more here: http://feedproxy.google.com/~r/whitmanpio/~3/ZwR0C0W3sl0/
Copyright 2026 Whitman Wire