Swashes buckled, hearts a-flutter

Originally Posted on The Yale Herald via UWIRE

You might not have the highest of expectations for a drama where significant chunks of the plot revolve around 18th-century tin mining, shareholder meetings, and whether there’s enough salt to preserve this year’s pilchard catch. You might be forgiven for assuming such a show would be dull. You’d be dead wrong with Poldark, however—the latest BBC drama airing as part of PBS’s Masterpiece programming block is nothing if not exciting. The show is filled to the brim with jailbreaks, shipwrecks, duels, fisticuffs, fabulous hats, shirtless scything, and polite-yet-cutting remarks exchanged over glasses of port. Poldark is a fun, sexy, and swashbuckling period drama that’s plenty binge-worthy.

Based on Winston Graham’s 1940s series of novels, Poldark was first adapted for the small screen back in 1975. The 29-episode original series proved wildly popular in the UK, having outsold every costume drama save Pride and Prejudice (1995). The new version is, in keeping with the times, glossier and more cinematic, with far higher production value. The premise is this: Captain Ross Poldark (Aidan Turner) has returned to Cornwall, England from a stint fighting for the Redcoats in the American Revolution with a comically inconsequential facial scar and a longing for his sweetheart, Elizabeth (Heida Reed). The only problem? After three years of thinking he was dead, Elizabeth is engaged to marry Ross’s cousin, Francis (Kyle Soller). On top of this, Ross’s father is dead, leaving behind only debt and a derelict estate. Did I say there was only one problem? My apologies. There are many problems.

The series’ main drama springs from two sources: Ross’s efforts to reinvigorate his mining operation, and the love quadrangle between Ross, Elizabeth, Francis, and Demelza (Eleanor Tomlinson), a boyish yet comely scullery maid Ross rescues after she flees her abusive father. Rounding out the main recurring cast are George Warleggan (Jack Farthing), an ambitious and vindictive banker who, for all his wealth, can’t forget that he’s a blacksmith’s grandson; Verity Poldark (Ruby Bentall), Francis’ kind-hearted and repressed sister; and Dwight Enys (Luke Norris), a principled doctor that Ross befriended on the battlefields of Virginia. Eighty-three year old Caroline Blakiston also merits a shout-out as the enormously entertaining Aunt Agatha, a rough analogue to Downton Abbey’s Violet Crawley if the latter were interested in tarot cards and revolvers.

Much of the show’s appeal comes from its leads. Turner, best known for playing the dwarf Kili in The Hobbit, absolutely oozes dark, brooding charisma as the hot headed Captain Poldark. He also takes his top off a lot, and even when it’s not off it’s one of those old timey billowy garments that expose a glimpse of solid rugged chest, so there’s that if you like. Tomlinson shines as the plucky, flame-haired Demelza, who many would argue is the real star of the show. She exudes the kind of spritely beauty that makes me want to use words like lass and waif and stand on a Cornish cliff staring dreamily at the sea, even though it’s 2016 and I live in Connecticut. But I digress. Suffice to say, the two are well-acted and possess the kind of chemistry that studio executives go mad trying to manufacture.

If the first goal of Poldark is to tell a rollicking romantic adventure and the second goal is to have Mr. Turner shirtless a lot, then a distant third consideration is exploring the trials and inequalities of late 18th-century English society. The series touches upon class, industrialisation, and warfare—not with a great deal of delicacy, but at least to a further extent than most period dramas. Importantly, Poldark is also excessively, self-consciously Cornish. From mining, to pilchards, to snatches of the ancient Kernowek language heard in a lullaby, this is a regional tale as much as a period one. The natural beauty of the Celtic south-west of England shines thanks to the cinematography. No plot thread or character seems able to develop without a sweeping shot of the dramatic coastline or the brilliant blue sea.

If that was enough to convince you to watch Poldark immediately, go forward with my blessing—season 1 is on Amazon Video. For the rest of you who need more convincing, allow me the luxury of providing a mild spoiler: the main characters all pair off and get married within the first few episodes of the first season. The question isn’t who ends up with who; it’s how everyone learns to live with their choices. Unlike many romances, marriage is not a happily-ever-after that concludes the story. Rather, it’s the beginning of a messy, complicated, lifelong relationship. Couples argue over money, children, and hundreds of other inconsequential things. They make terrible decisions and occasionally do horrible things to each other. But thanks to strong writing and performances, the viewer still wants to root for each imperfect character. It’s a refreshing approach to romantic dramas, which are all too often built around the “Will-They-Won’t-They” tension and subsequently fizzles out once “They Do.”

Of course, the show is not without flaws. The drama can verge on soapy; there are also a few episodes that probably don’t need to feature as much tin mining as they do. Because the show adapts approximately two novels per 8-10 episode season, the pace can seem a bit rushed. In the grand tradition of stories set in the 18th century but written in the 20th, Poldark also features an anachronistically progressive hero. Captain Ross is endearingly fond of running around Cornwall, insulting his fellow aristocrats and saying things like “Social class is a construct! The Americans were right! Bankers are evil!”

For die-hard fans of period dramas, romance novels, handsome men, old fashioned adventure tales, and the intricacies of 18th-century Cornish tin mining, Poldark is unmissable. For everyone else, it’s still a pretty diverting way to spend an evening. Bodices will be ripped, swashes will be buckled, and poor decisions will be made, all in the most entertaining of fashions. Watch it. Or don’t. I’m not your mom, although if your mom is looking for a new show post-Downton Abbey this is the one to point her towards.

Read more here: http://yaleherald.com/reviews/swashes-buckled-hearts-a-flutter/
Copyright 2026 The Yale Herald