Anti-Intellectualism ruins the Republican party

Originally Posted on Whitman Wire via UWIRE

Republican anti-intellectualism historically has never been a significant problem when nominating leadership because the party has always nominated intelligent men into its leadership. Eisenhower, Nixon, Reagan, Bush senior were all highly competent career politicians running on working-class common man platforms. What differentiates past conservative presidents and more contemporary Republican presidential hopefuls is that past politicians have been opposed to intellectual pursuits without being radical in their beliefs. The shift towards incompetent and ignorant candidates is driven by a hard truth for the Republican party; Moderate Republicans, even with fantastic resumes, don’t win anymore.

John McCain in 2008, Mitt Romney in 2012, John Kasich in 2016, each one of these politicians were remarkably capable, moderate, politicians who either failed to beat a moderate Democrat, or failed to win his party’s nomination. McCain was by all means a party golden boy. A bona fide war hero with an immaculate resume, McCain’s defeat signaled a political shift in the party. Shortly after the loss the Tea Party began to be more of force with American conservatism. This growth of radicalism in the form of the Tea Party emboldened more radical candidates from within the party to pursue the nomination for president in 2012.

Men like Newt Gingrich, Rick Santorum, and Rick Perry all campaigned with some success on platforms of radical nature. These candidates lost the nomination to Mitt Romney. Romney’s loss opened the floodgates for Trump. During the 2016 Republican race for the nomination a horde of party outcasts, firebrands, and nobodies not only campaigned well, but stole the election from moderates selected by party leadership to win in 2016. John Kasich and Marco Rubio were decimated at the polls, despite being the candidates backed by party elites. Scott Walker, Carly Fiorina, Rick Santorum, Mike Huckabee, Ted Cruz and Ben Carson all campaigned well. These candidates were largely radical, largely inexperienced, and almost entirely rejected by the party.

The man himself who carried the nomination away, Trump, may realistically not be the worst character that ran for the nomination in 2016. By appealing to undereducated voters and creating a party persona that rejected intellectualism the Republican party allowed Trump to take the nomination. For the first time in recent memory, the Republican party has produced a genuinely stupid candidate, and not a candidate who underplays his intelligence to be more approachable to voters.

The Republican candidate of today does not represent American conservatism. Many of America’s greatest conservative lawmakers and political commentators neither shrunk from debate nor compromised their beliefs for the party. The GOP is fractured now but will repair itself. It created a candidate who proved to be its undoing, and now it will pay for it.

Read more here: http://feedproxy.google.com/~r/whitmanpio/~3/OUgp_0bYUy0/
Copyright 2026 Whitman Wire