
The start of the college football season is so tantalizingly close; the last few weeks of the offseason always seem to be the slowest. Teams across the nation finally beginning to practice, and season previews and predictions are appearing in abundance across the media. As the offseason drags on to its much anticipated conclusion, I propose an idea that may allow the season to start sooner while serving the needs of coaches and players: would college football teams, much like teams in the NFL, benefit from scheduling an additional exhibition game prior to the regular season? Let’s look at the pros and cons of this new proposal.
Pro: It would be good for the fans. Adding a week of preseason games would serve to lengthen the college football season, which could really use a boost. College football has the shortest season of any major North American sport, in terms of both number of events and percentage of the calendar year that it occupies. The maximum number of games a team could play is 15, while most teams only see 13 games per year (12 regular season games plus a bowl game). For comparison, the NFL has the next-smallest schedule at 16 regular season games and up to four playoff games, in addition to the four-week preseason. The whole season itself also takes place over just four months, a mark rivaled only by college basketball. An additional week of exhibition games before the season starts would alleviate that problem and give football-starved fans something to chew on.
Con: It could be detrimental to player safety. Of course, while the fans may enjoy an extra week of action, the players may not be willing to put their bodies on the line for ultimately meaningless preseason games. All it would take is one major concussion or ligament tear for players to unite in opposition to the exhibitions. A major injury in a preseason game could also spoil a team’s season before it even begins, souring both fan interest and national attention.
Pro: It would allow coaches to evaluate the depth chart against comparable competition. In the current state of college football, third- and fourth-string players basically only ever see the field in blowout games against much lower competition (such as FCS teams). If schools scheduled preseason games against teams of similar caliber, the coaches, media, and fans would have a better understanding of the depth of talent on the team without risking a loss on their record.
Con: Pollsters could still take the exhibitions into consideration when ranking teams. Even though the games would not count in any official standings, pollsters may still use the outcomes to determine their weekly rankings. Whether it is a conscious decision or not, a blowout, an upset or even an unimpressive performance in an exhibition game could sour the team’s perception in the minds of the pollsters. This could snowball into the season, leaving a team perpetually under-ranked and possibly even out of a deserved playoff spot.
Pro: It could diminish or eliminate boring tune-up games against FCS schools. Most teams spend the first game of the season against much weaker schools in order to basically serve as a live practice while guaranteeing a win on the schedule. While these games serve a purpose to the team, they are almost always snooze fests for the fans, who are not compelled to watch a blowout against an unknown school. Exhibition games would fill that role, eliminating the need for a tune-up game while having no chance at impacting the standings. This aspect would also enable teams to schedule preseason games against quality opponents, since the final score does not matter anyway.
Con: It may not be good for the fans. No matter how exciting the matchup may seem, fans may not be compelled to watch or care if they know that the game does not count. This would ultimately bring college football back to the very state in which it currently resides — with meaningless, unexciting games to open the season. At that point, why make any changes at all?
Overall, college football may stand to benefit from implementing a week of exhibition games prior to the start of the season. At the very least, it is a discussion worth having among fans before toe finally meets leather.