There are two types of people: those who willingly admit that they love pop music and those who don’t. However, those who admit to enjoying pop music do so in an embarrassed sort-of ironic way, referring to them as their “guilty pleasure” and those who shun pop music are just plain above it, because alternative music is so much more “mature,” “complex” and “creative.” But let’s be real. Pop music is not a genre of our young and naive past, just one that is greatly misunderstood.
We’re are beginning to confuse the meaning of “pop music.” By definition, popular music is exactly that: music that is popular. Just because Taylor Swift is at the top of the Billboard Hot 100 right now, it doesn’t mean her style is all that pop is.While T-Swift, Meghan Trainor and Tove Lo are ruling the charts today, chart-toppers in the 1960s included, Elvis Presley, The Beatles and The Supremes—all of which fall under the umbrella of pop.
Clearly the label “pop” says nothing about genre because these pop artists don’t sound anything alike. It’s true that music that ends up being popular often has one of the common themes of romantic relationships or partying and a repetitive melody, but that doesn’t change its quality.
Taylor Jones, the music director for the University of Oregon campus radio station, KWVA, agrees with this. “I don’t think pop can be defined by the music qualities of the artist that is said popular,” said Jones. Pop music isn’t limited to the specific style that is popular at one time.
It’s ridiculous that enjoying a popular song, album or artist is now viewed as embarrassing or in need of an excuse. If you buy the new Taylor Swift album, you must refer to it as a guilty pleasure or present it as a joke. Why does anyone need an excuse to enjoy some catchy tunes that make you feel good?
“Catchy tunes and hooks are not easy to write. Pop music that’s so catchy and tuneful that lots and lots of people like it, I don’t think that’s a bad thing,” said Greg Sutherland, the owner of House of Records, a popular record store here in Eugene since 1971.
A lot of this revolves around the paradox that once everyone knows about and likes a work of art, it stops being good. For example, you might be totally in love with this band that you started listening to way before anyone else. But as soon as they start getting airplay on Z100, you decide they’re not worth your attention.
Though Jones admits to feeling more intimately connected to artists when they’re less not as well-known, he believes that “artists can still be just as good artistically no matter what their following is, whether they’re the most popular band in the world or nobody knows who they are.”
Realistically, that band hasn’t changed one bit. They’re still that same cool band that you “discovered.” For some reason, we have this idea that the more popular an artist or song gets, the lower the quality the music is.
Of course, everyone likes what they like, and if you happen to sincerely cringe at whatever is popular right now, I’m not here to tell you that’s wrong. Instead, I’m suggesting that we stop hating on pop music simply based on its label. It’s not fair to rule out such a huge group of artists solely because they’ve received radio time or made it to the Billboard charts.
Sure, some pop music is naive, poorly written and sounds the same as a lot of other things. But so does a lot of alternative music. Don’t be the music snob who refuses to listen to anything pop, or any other genre with a stereotype.
As Sutherland explains, “We label things, and those labels fall short. We have to label things to know what they are, to find them. But it hems them in a lot of times. ”
Listen to all different artists and evaluate them for yourself instead of letting a stigma decide for you.
Follow Lindsay McWilliams on Twitter @lindsaymacwill