After a tumultuous offseason, a question that three years ago would have been inconceivable now seems inevitable.
Should Oregon men’s basketball coach Dana Altman’s job be in question?
This upcoming season will be a crucial time to review whether he is the best man suited for the job.
The role of a head coach changes from person to person. Some are simply judged based on wins and losses — nothing else matters. Some are judged based on whether or not the captain at the helm will be able to sculpt and mold his young charges into model citizens, instilling important life lessons and morals.
Unfortunately for Altman, he doesn’t seem to fit either expectation.
When Altman was brought in, the hope was that he would be able to translate his impressive resume into a winning Duck program. Altman enjoyed the most success with Creighton, the team he was hired from. There he posted a 327-176 (.650) record and seven NCAA Tournament appearances in his 16 seasons.
The 2010-11 season was Altman’s debut as a Duck, taking over a team that struggled in conference play with a 7-11 record.
Two seasons was all it took for him to turn things around.
Altman seems to be able to form deep bonds with his players, squeezing out every bit of talent from athletes who would be mediocre in another setting. He trusts his players to make smart decisions while allowing them to attack the basket with ferocity.
Additionally, Altman has become the master of recruiting transfers, bringing in veteran players like Devoe Joseph, Arsalan Kazemi and Mike Moser for one-and-done seasons.
Everything came together for Altman in the 2012-13 season. Combining some key transfers with promising freshmen, Altman was able to lead the Ducks to a 28-8 record (12-6 Pac-12) that included a Pac-12 Tournament Championship alongside a Sweet Sixteen finish in the NCAA Tournament, where they lost to eventual National Champion Louisville. For all of his efforts, Altman was awarded Pac-12 Coach of the Year.
The promise of that year has now completely worn off after a tough off-season. Everyone knows the story: The men’s basketball team was rocked by an alleged sexual assault case that implicated three players (Damyean Dotson, Brandon Austin and Dominic Artis.) The team released all three while many other players jumped ship, transferring away from the program. The team also lost several incoming freshmen, after five-star recruit JaQuan Lyle and Canadian big-man Ray Kasongo were both denied admission. As the dust settled, what was left on Altman’s roster was a skeleton crew devoid of any experience.
Let’s not kid ourselves, this upcoming season is going to be brutal. Several Pac-12 preseason rankings have Oregon down at No. 9 in the Pac-12. Altman may be skilled at developing players, but there comes a point when a lack of talent trumps all. The only player on this squad with any proven consistency is Joseph Young, and the impending triple teams should wipe that out fairly quickly.
The other red flag is the continued character issues. Just recently two players were caught shoplifting, which is deeply concerning coming off the heels of everything else. With each new issue, it becomes harder and harder to believe Altman has any control over this group.
Fan pressure is what usually causes coaching changes and by the end of the season, Altman and the Ducks should be feeling plenty of it. Perhaps that isn’t such a bad thing. This whole situation screams for a reboot. Altman is a good coach and a change of scenery would allow him to go back to focusing on basketball. Meanwhile, a coaching change would re-energize the Duck fan base and bring excitement back to a stoic Matthew Knight Arena.
Altman will survive this year, but in the off-season serious conversations as to whether he remains the best choice to lead this team must be had.
Follow Christopher Keizur on Twitter @chriskeizur