The first time I witnessed a cyber-brawl was in eighth grade, during MySpace’s demise. A girl at my school posted a “bulletin” (which were essentially discussion boards) saying that true love isn’t found in junior high.
Upon viewing it, I realized online discussions were held to completely different standards. I refreshed the page until I hit gold: “you don’t even know what ur talking about … I [know] so many ppl that met and fell IN LOVE in middle school and are still married. so just relax. ur not dr. phil BEEZY.”
Some defended the girl, but each response remained just as mean-spirited as the first. Now, as I look through Facebook and Twitter almost six years later, nothing has changed. It begs the question: what gives us our electronic courage, and why has it erased everything we were taught about how to be civil?
If you’re one of the 14,619 followers of the University of Oregon Confessions page on Facebook, you’ve probably come across its colorful variety of anonymous submissions in your newsfeed. I categorized a few of them:
Encouragement: “If Internet Explorer is brave enough to ask to be your default browser, then you can be brave enough to ask that girl/girl out!” (258 likes)
Innovation: “I didn’t shave my legs this weekend so that the drunk me would be less motivated to take off my pants. #whitegirlwasted” (282 likes)
Or, (my personal favorite,) mental breakdown: “I give up on school. I just want to roll around on the floor with my blanket and be a burrito for the rest of my life.” (762 likes)
The page, which posted its first submission in December 2012, offers UO students the opportunity to send in “confessions” anonymously through a third-party website called CollegeTickr. It doesn’t take much digging to discover that some individuals used the page as a way to post offensive material without risking judgment by their peers. The comments can be worse, and submitting a confession could produce dozens of them.
UO psychology professor Sara Hodges notes that some of the negative content on the page could be considered cyber-bullying — which is especially damaging when the anonymous poster is seeking help.
“Some may use the site to try and test the waters,” Hodges said. She also mentions that some elements of crowd psychology may apply to students who comment on the page with an opinion they wouldn’t voice in a face-to-face conversation. After the first insult is thrown, bystanders feel comfortable enough to echo the harassment.
On the other hand, sympathetic and supportive responses showcase the potential benefits of the page, Hodges said.
Freshman biology major Erik Glasrud often defends the people he believes are being unfairly targeted.
“There is so much on there that is bigoted and offensive that I make a point of going on [the posts] and arguing in the comments,” he said. Despite his disappointment with the page’s content, however, it hasn’t changed the way he views the university community. “People are like this everywhere. I knew people like that in high school … it’s almost unavoidable,” he said. “I’m trying to spread a little good because that page can be so hateful.”
But the harassment doesn’t stop there. Anonymous submission pages on Twitter have aimed to create a pithier, yet more entertaining alternative to the UO Confessions page.
Take Oregon Crushes for example, a Twitter page where you can woo (or sexually harass) the object of your affection from a safe distance. It’s like middle school on steroids.
“Cute ginger boy sitting alone, reading in Hamilton on Tuesday u are a dream boat,” an anonymous tweeter said.
Or, if you’re the visual type, you can join the 2,101 followers of the UO Makeouts page. It tweets pictures of (usually intoxicated) people making out at parties with or without the consent of the individuals engaging in the act.
When asked about the legal and ethical issues associated with the content of their posts, the account moderators, who chose to remain anonymous and communicate only through email, recommended that, “if you don’t want to be put on the account because of your personal life, your occupation or social status, then we recommend that you don’t make out at a party in the first place.”
Those are harsh words, especially considering that some of the photos could potentially earn the account a lawsuit. Any time a photo of someone is posted on a public forum, said the Emerald’s attorney Andrew Lewis, there is a risk of liability. That risk only increases if the image in question was obtained on private property.
But placing the blame solely on the account moderators is an oversimplification of a far more complex social issue. While they certainly aren’t helping, we — as supporters and consumers of the content — are doubly as guilty for allowing the pages to be a place where racist, sexist and hurtful attitudes can thrive. So, every once in a while — maybe when you feel that urge to quickly scroll up to un-see an awful comment on YouTube — use your electronic courage to fight back.