For the Record: Investigation confirms 10 instances of fabrication by former Emerald reporter

Originally Posted on Emerald Media via UWIRE

Editor’s note: We’ve penned a blog post addressing many of the questions our readers have had about the process we went through from the time we began the investigation until this story was published. Find it here.

A former Emerald reporter fabricated quotes for 10 different sources during her five months working at the paper, an internal audit conducted by the organization’s news editors found. Food writer Jessica Fisher made up quotes for six sources who were never interviewed for the stories they were quoted in. She also misquoted three sources and falsified one source.

The audit — led by Senior News Editor Ian Campbell — also found eight instances where sources could not be verified after multiple attempts to contact them.

This problem came to the Emerald’s attention on Jan. 23, when University of Oregon undergraduate student Ashley Adelman called the Emerald’s office to notify editors that she was quoted in that day’s cover story, but was never interviewed. This instantly raised red flags for the paper’s management staff.

After apologizing to Adelman, editors removed the story and called Fisher in to give her a chance to prove the interview was real with either audio clips or written notes.

Upon making contact with Fisher, a sophomore journalism and advertising student, she admitted to fabricating the interview and quit via a note left on the staircase leading up to the Emerald offices on the EMU’s third floor.

In a letter to Emerald Editor in Chief Sam Stites on Feb. 25, Fisher expressed her regrets and apologized to Stites, her editors, the Emerald’s staff and the campus community.

“

I should have quit from week one really, but I didn’t and allowed myself to take shortcuts,” Fisher wrote. “These shortcuts — although temporary in easing my stresses — have hurt you, your staff and your publication, so widely cherished around our campus and beyond.”

Stites wrote a letter from the editor in late January accepting responsibility for unacceptable and unprofessional practices. With the culmination of the investigation, Stites responded to the findings.

“This type of work does not represent the hard work and integrity of the rest of the Emerald staff,” Stites said. “Since this incident, we are taking greater measures to ensure the validity of facts and sources across all platforms. We regret the errors and strive to regain the trust and good faith of our community.”

Adelman was quoted in the lead of the story “Eugene’s Sweet Potato Pie and Greater Goods lead the charge to carry Fair Trade clothing.” She was falsely attributed explaining where she shops and why she chooses those locations to purchase her clothes.

One of the first instances found to be fabricated was in the cover story “Food: To vegan or not to vegan?” published on Nov. 7, 2013. Fisher quoted Jaime Dexter-Enriquez — a graduate teaching fellow in the UO’s anthropology department — on the evolution of modern-day agriculture. Dexter-Enriquez confirmed that she was completely misquoted and proved the fabrication by providing email correspondence between herself and Fisher that were contrary to what Fisher put in her story.

The eight unverifiable sources were not able to be found through Internet searches, cold calls, networking, Facebook and Twitter exploration. Six other sources were contacted, but never responded to emails or phone calls, raising questions regarding their legitimacy.

After more incidents of fabrication were confirmed, Emerald editors began to remove the articles with false facts and quotes . A list of these stories can be found below.

Since this discovery, the Emerald is working to correct the system that allowed Fisher to fabricate information. Reporters and writers are now required to give contact information for all their stories’ sources. Copy editors randomly check these contacts to verify validity and accuracy. It is impractical to check all sources, but we are working to set a higher standard of fact checking and rebuild the trust of our community. Please direct any questions to Stites, who is available via email (sstites@dailyemerald.com), phone (541-346-5511 ext. 325) or in person at EMU Suite 300.

The following stories have been removed from the Emerald’s website:

– Eugene’s Sweet Potato Pie and Greater Goods lead the charge to carry Fair Trade clothing (Jan. 23, 2014)

– From yogurt to Kombucha, plenty of foods benefit from a bit of fermentation (Jan. 16, 2014)

– Portland isn’t the only place with great food, check out Eugene’s food carts (Jan. 13, 2014)

– Eugene’s charming neighborhoods have much to offer students (Jan. 9, 2014)

– Crumb Together, right now (Dec. 2, 2013)

– Eugene’s indoor farmers’ market has you covered for holiday gifts (Nov. 27, 2013)

– ‘Neighbors Helping Neighbors’: Whiteaker’s 25th annual community dinner (Nov. 26, 2013)

– From classy to quirky: 10 Eugene restaurants with great ambiance (Nov. 22, 2013)

– Restaurant preview: Grit brings rustic charm to the Whiteaker neighborhood (Nov. 18, 2013)

– Want free food? The Student Food Pantry has you covered (Nov. 14, 2013)

– Food: To vegan or not to vegan? (Nov. 7, 2013)

– Talented local chef talks slow food, creativity and making dreams come true (Oct. 24, 2013)

– Where freshman have it good: New dorm dining options (Sept. 26, 2013)

Read more here: http://dailyemerald.com/2014/03/10/for-the-record-investigation-confirms-10-instances-of-fabrication-by-former-emerald-reporter/
Copyright 2026 Emerald Media