When one turns on the TV to watch the Grammys, one must be aware of who’s running it. The Grammy bosses aren’t music critics or pop culture cognoscenti, but industry suits who have been part of the business since the days of payola and Presley. They’re people who still hold on to the vision of the pop industry as it was during its first four and a half decades of existence — a thriving market driven by a form of music with tremendous power over cultural currents. Everything that wins at the Grammys hearkens back to this model in some way — if it’s easily digestible by audiences and/or still has the power to change popular attitudes, it’s likely to be snatched up.
The 2012-2013 music “season” represented at the 56th Annual Grammy Awards Ceremony must have been orgasmic for the National Academy Of Recording Arts & Sciences. This was an incredible time for pop music, with weirdos like Lorde scoring Top 10 singles and juggernauts like Justin Timberlake and Daft Punk returning to the industry as if they’d never left. It was also — at least the way a Bob Dylan-raised label bigwig might see it — a good year for rap. The genre produced arguably the 2010s’ first instant classic in Kendrick Lamar’s “good kid, m.A.A.d city,” as well as a politically “progressive” yet commercially appealing rap duo called Macklemore & Ryan Lewis.
Macklemore & Ryan Lewis won the first award of the night, best new artist, following an embarrassing intro from host LL Cool J and a glorious introductory performance from Beyoncé that found her not looking at husband/collaborator Jay-Z as they sang a duet about them having crazy sex. The nominees in this category were a bit strange given how few of them are truly “new.” Only nominee Kacey Musgraves has not been popular for over two years, but were the category to consist only of artists that got big in 2013, it might have to change its name to “most obscenely rapid rise.” As it is now, it should be called “breakthrough of the year.”
That Lorde did not receive a nomination in this category is understandable given her wins for best pop solo performance and song of the year, but of all the performers there, her presence was the most visible reminder of how strange 2013′s pop climate truly was. Her awkward presence set her apart from the confident pop idols she competed and won against. And her stripped-down performance of “Royals” was terrifying — I’ve never seen anyone dance so fluidly to sub-bass frequencies. In an era when indie, alternative and pop are one, someone like Lorde could easily be a superstar.
Yet the most formidable presence at the Grammys was Daft Punk, flanked by an ensemble seemingly forged in the music industry’s Mount Doom —Nile Rodgers, a Smokey the Bear-hatted Pharrell and, during their second televised performance in history, Stevie Wonder. The robots won album of the year and dance/electronic album of the year for “Random Access Memories” as well as record of the year for their uberhit “Get Lucky.”
Daft Punk’s wins should have surprised no one. “Random Access Memories” is recorded with the same overbearing care as pop’s greatest statements, from “Aja” to “Thriller” to Beyoncé’s “4.” It’s overflowing with nostalgia for the disco days, when the industry dominated all. And, perhaps most importantly, it has a smash hit.
The rest of the ceremony was more classic Grammy fare, though some of the ideas could have only come from an organization as mad with power as the National Academy Of Recording Arts & Sciences. Chicago with Robin Thicke was bizarre and felt like some last-minute attempt to troll Thicke. Metallica performing with Chinese concert pianist Lang Lang was entertaining, though coming after a tribute to Lou Reed their performance felt like a misguided Hollywood funeral. The jam at the end with Pat Smear, the two surviving Beatles, and the two surviving Nirvana members was fun to witness — though those sorts of all-star performances aren’t as entertaining as the simple, weird mashups.
2014′s Grammys were no less a music industry nostalgia-fest than usual, but coming after a year with such an unusually compelling top 200 climate, the sentiment was justified. Daft Punk’s triumphant return, Lorde’s oddness, even Macklemore’s politics-as-novelty made the awards’ celebration of pop music history seem timely. Katy Perry may have had her moment in the spotlight, and Paul and Ringo jamming with some grunge goons is still the closest we’ll get to a Beatles reunion. But there’s no going back, and given how much incredible pop music was released in the season before the 56th Annual Grammy Awards, wanting to go back would accomplish nothing.