Before the Beatles were the archetypal late ’60s band, they were the archetypal early ’60s band — a pop group with great ideas that was nonetheless controlled by cigar-chomping, music industry sleazebags. They were made to wear matching suits, they made goofy movies, their music was released on as many mini-albums, regional albums and EPs as suited their labels’ financial needs.
“With the Beatles,” released Nov. 22, 1963, is early ’60s Beatles in a nutshell, meaning it’s simultaneously the most representative album of their early music and the one that most obviously displays the conflict between their ideas and those of their music-industry superiors. It’s essentially a clone of their previous album, “Please Please Me,” with a similar structure and an abundance of covers. Its quality has everything to do with the quality of the individual songs rather than its merits as an album or as “revolutionary” music.
Luckily, it’s not that inferior to “Please Please Me,” and it’s not at all bad. In fact, it’s very good, particularly the first half — which, by no coincidence, contains most of the original songs. The opening song, “It Won’t Be Long,” isn’t that lyrically impressive but it’s a great opener, hurling you into the album with a maximum-energy John Lennon shout. Significantly better is the underrated “All I’ve Got to Do” with a beautiful, harmony-guided chorus initiated by a cathartic shout of “And the same goes for me!”
Paul McCartney’s “All My Loving” keeps the flow of the album going because it is more aggressive than the previous track but less so than “It Won’t Be Long.” It’s also pretty great as a pop song, and the change in rhythmic feel between the verse and chorus predicts McCartney’s penchant for songs that flow naturally through disparate sections.
The next two songs, the low-key “Don’t Bother Me” and the awful “Little Child,” are less interesting — though the former is the first George Harrison-penned song on any Beatles album. But the next track blows every other track that came before it to shame. “Till There Was You,” a McCartney-helmed cover of a tune from “The Music Man,” is one of the Beatles’ best covers. It’s also the most forward-looking track on the album. Dominated by bongos and jazzy guitar, “Till There Was You” almost predicts the unconventional baroque-pop soundscapes they would implement on their psychedelic albums.
“Please Mister Postman” is the album’s other best cover. It’s superior to the original Marvelettes version and also a lot more aggressive. But after it fades out, side two kicks off with Chuck Berry’s “Roll Over Beethoven.” Maybe it’s just my Chuck Berry bias — I cannot stand his music — but it seems very unpromising. It’s a very generic song to cover, and outside of the context of the rock-band-as-cultural-commodity, there doesn’t seem to be much value to it. At least “You Really Got a Hold on Me,” the song they cover next, is impossible to cover poorly.
The other two cover songs are better. At least until the Flying Lizards came along, the Beatles version of Barrett Strong’s “Money (That’s What I Want)” stood as definitive, and it’s pretty good despite being an obvious substitute for “Please Please Me’s” exponentially superior “Twist And Shout.” “Devil in Her Heart” is a gorgeous cover of a song by ultra-obscure girl group The Donays. It’s the only real obscurity on the album despite the Beatles’ extensive knowledge of pop music, which would put many of today’s most obsessive Internet-raised music nerds to shame.
As for the originals on this side, none of them are particularly remarkable. “Hold Me Tight” has a weird, relentless groove that would be unnerving if not for the cheesy lyrics, and it feels above all else like a missed opportunity. Lennon’s “Not a Second Time” has a fantastic piano solo and little else, while “I Wanna Be Your Man” is more solid but less fun than the version by The Rolling Stones, whom they initially gave the song to.
Though “With the Beatles” isn’t equal to its predecessor, it’s the Beatles album that gives the clearest insight into what sort of environment they were working with in 1963. But it is vital to understand that the Beatles subverted every empty financial decision their management threw at them. While they wore matching suits at interviews, they responded to reporters with leather-jacket irreverence. When they had to make a movie a la Elvis, they made an artsy comedy film, “A Hard Day’s Night.” And when they had to pump out albums to fuel the hype machine — well, they made great music.