Detroit MC has a lot to prove on his third album

Originally Posted on Emerald Media via UWIRE

At this point in Danny Brown’s career, his persona is strongly threatening to overshadow his work. There’s the infamous head-on-stage incident in Minnesota. There’s his hair and the whole mythos surrounding being rejected from labels because of his skinny jeans. And, of course, there’s his voice — polarizing enough that it puts a lot of people off from getting into his music. It’s been two years since XXX, his brilliant second album and his guest verses have become increasingly flimsy. In other words, he has a lot to prove on his latest album Old.

From the first track, “Old,” it’s clear Brown is using the third album as a platform to establish himself as a presence in the hip-hop industry. He’s a veteran twice over, first appearing as a thirty-year old newcomer and now a patriarch of the waning swag-rap movement — and the first side of the album asserts this aggressively. Brown’s flow is ridiculously dense and is hard to follow without a lyric sheet, but the discernable lines hit hard. There’s almost an Illmatic vibe to some of the tracks on Old‘s first side, using understatement and grim humor to paint vivid pictures of street life.

Most remarkable among these is “Wonderbread” — a two-minute vignette that’s possibly Danny Brown’s best song and easily the album’s best. The song details Brown walking through the violence-ridden streets of Detroit on the way to get groceries. The donkey bray he employs on the song sounds a bit ludicrous, but it’s also terrified. Brown’s flow on “Wonderbread” is similar to Kendrick Lamar’s on “m.A.A.d city,” creating the impression of a scared kid, hyperventilating and rapping furiously as if for dear life.

Old accomplishes its goal in establishing that Danny Brown can rap, and makes an extremely compelling case for his ability to continue making good music. But many of the stylistic experiments Brown attempts on the album fail miserably. “25 Bucks,” a collaboration with MDMA-pop duo Purity Ring, comes in the middle of the album’s darkest and most lyrically impressive sections. It, along with the unnecessary oral sex ode “Dope Fiend” three songs later, severely drags down the flow of the side.

Worse, these clunkers become more frequent the deeper you go into the album. Old‘s gigantic structural flaw is the sequencing of the more serious tracks before the more party-oriented tracks. This is the reverse of XXX, which was impressive for pulling back the curtain on the man behind the hedonistic persona in its second half. The man on the party anthems does not usually feel like the same man describing watching a crackhead burn his lip off on the first side. It’s almost as if they’re two separate EPs. The party songs would be a fine EP by themselves, and many of them are quite good, but they dull the impression left by the songs on Side A once the album is over.

Yet there’s certainly enough good material here to constitute an excellent album. Old could be great at 24 minutes, or 45 minutes, but the near-hour of roughly half of what I would classify as filler or failed experiments does not succeed often enough to be truly great or establish Brown as a major hip-hop force. After listening to Old, I have faith in Danny Brown’s talent–but I don’t have much faith in his taste.

Read more here: http://dailyemerald.com/2013/10/31/detroit-mc-has-a-lot-to-prove-on-his-third-album/
Copyright 2026 Emerald Media