Kim: An overdue game of inches

Originally Posted on Emerald Media via UWIRE

Mark Helfrich is late to the party.

It’s been three games and the competition between Alejandro Maldonado and Matt Wogan has already dragged on too long. The Ducks may not have suffered in the kicking department thus far in the season, but they know as well as anyone that it only takes one kick to change the course of a season, especially when they are competing for a title.

For Helfrich, the kicking competition has boiled down to a game of inches. Both kickers have only combined for four total field goals this season and, according to Helfrich, the only difference between the two has been a switch off between who makes it and who doesn’t.

“When you look at those field goals, one was good by about five inches and one missed by about five inches,” Helfrich said.

But for kickers, there are two areas that should never be touched: confidence and consistency. These two go hand-in-hand in regard to a kicker’s success and both areas have been tampered with by alternating Maldonado and Wogan.

This is not a question of picking your poison, but more about picking your guy for the year. Either the Ducks need to take their chances with Maldonado — who has already missed one from 37 yards — or go with Wogan who has been praised for his big leg.

Helfrich may be trying to give his older player one last chance to prove everyone wrong, but when your team has a legitimate chance to compete for a national championship, favors aren’t a part of the equation.

Having said that, why not give the fresh legs a chance? Wogan may be an unproven freshman, but he’s made his one field goal attempt on the year and has gone 10-11 on PAT’s (one was blocked), which is all the Ducks need. If the Ducks truly wish to develop Wogan into a reliable kicker, they need to give him more reps.

Considering what Maldonado has gone through in his first two years, there are no guarantees what will happen when he is put into a situation similar to the Stanford game last season. The mental aspect of a kicker is very sensitive and somewhere along the line, Maldonado may have already lost it.

Hayden Kim, senior sports reporter.

Hayden Kim, senior sports reporter.

Making 60-yard field goals in practice is impressive, but the conversation immediately goes out the window when a kicker can’t convert go-aheads in real game situations. This has been the reality for Maldonado.

Fair or not, Wogan has been the more consistent of the two this year and has shown to have a stronger leg, something the Ducks have been sorely lacking the past few years.

Whether the Ducks decide to go with Maldonado or Wogan, they will need to choose both wisely and quickly. The season—more often than not—comes down to a kick or two and they will need to make it happen when the time comes. This may be the year the Ducks get over the hump, but they will need a kicker on their side, like it or not.

Read more here: http://dailyemerald.com/2013/09/26/kim-an-overdue-game-of-inches/
Copyright 2026 Emerald Media