O’Gara: The trolls threatening podcasting’s future are patently absurd

Originally Posted on Emerald Media via UWIRE

A little over a year ago, when I was but a young and dumb columnist for this very media outlet, I wrote this: “If film was the art form of the 20th century, then the podcast is the art form of this century.”

That column is a rarity since it’s about something I like rather than something I dislike or don’t understand, and therefore fear, such as Macklemore or football. But there are people – accurately called patent trolls – operating in the darkest corners of the legal realm, actively trying to destroy one of the few things on this entire planet that I love, podcasts. This makes me so sad. AND MAD!

First, what is a patent troll?

Let us consult Wikipedia: “(A patent troll is) a person or company that enforces its patents against one or more alleged infringers in a manner considered unduly aggressive or opportunistic, often with no intention to manufacture or market the product.”

The troll relevant to my sadness is a company called Personal Audio, which in the ’90s tried to make an early digital audio player. That didn’t quite work out, but Personal Audio still retains its vaguely worded patents, and even though the company doesn’t make anything anymore (It’s a shell company), it uses those patents to file lawsuits that can be best described as legalized extortion — and they make millions of dollars.

Personal Audio is endangering the livelihoods of podcasters such as Jesse Thorn (who hosts “Bullseye!”), Marc Maron of “WTF” and even God himself, Ira Glass, whose “This American Life” program most recently investigated what happens “when patents attack.”

If the trolls win, we all lose. Artists will not be able to cross bridges and explore the limits of their creativity. The boundaries of the culture will be constricted and humanity will asphyxiate.

We live in a country with a government explicitly charged with protecting the intellectual and artistic property of creators. Article I, Section 8, Clause 8 of the Constitution tells the Congress “(t)o promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries.”

Since the people who wrote the Constitution capitalized all those words, it was obviously rather important to them. So, they’d be pleased that we’ve done a pretty good job protecting Writings and Discoveries from opportunistic trolls; however, while doing so, a legal system has developed preventing further Writings and Discoveries.

Great artists steal — that’s like basic Picasso wisdom or whatever. It’d be more accurate to say that great artists borrow, however. Painters rifle through the galleries of dead painters. Writers plunder the sentences of other, canonized writers. Filmmakers lift entire scenes first shot by their idols, who in turn lifted from their idols. This isn’t plagiarism; this is how art works.

In order to truly “promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts,” we need a different copyright framework, one that gives more room for “stealing.” If we all indeed stand on the shoulders of giants, we must ensure that they are not toppled by trolls.

Read more here: http://dailyemerald.com/2013/06/06/ogara-the-trolls-threatening-podcastings-future-are-patently-absurd/
Copyright 2026 Emerald Media