Editorial: Penn State should consider forfeiting remainder of season

By Daily Nebraskan Editorial Board

The last few days have been tumultuous for Pennsylvania State U., to say the least.

The Penn State athletic program has been rocked by scandal. Wednesday night saw the removal of longtime coach Joe Paterno and university President Graham Spanier, with the athletic director and vice president still facing charges of perjury. Following the announcements, students took to the streets in anger.

And through all of it, Penn State had to look toward Saturday with its last home game in mind.

Discussions among administrators, fans and bloggers since Wednesday night have brought forth a number of reasons for altering Saturday’s planned Nebraska-Penn State game. Safety of players is the primary concern, and Penn State announced Thursday that receivers coach Mike McQueary, who reported an alleged abuse to Paterno in 2002, will not be on the sidelines for the game, due to “multiple threats.”

Fearing both an unfair game atmosphere following Penn State’s change of coaches and the safety of Nebraska fans and players in a volatile atmosphere, commentators have offered ideas from NU Regent Tim Clare’s undefined “Plan B” to a one-game forfeit to the most extreme option: Penn State forfeiting the season.

Although certainly the most maligned of the three options, the Daily Nebraskan would like to defend the season forfeit. The DN editorial board believes the athletic and administrative departments of PSU should at least consider forfeiting the remainder of its football games.

With three games remaining — against Nebraska, Ohio State and Wisconsin — the DN sees value in the possibility of Penn State suspending its on-field operations as a football team and instead turn to what is most important: addressing and fixing the issues of distrust, disgust and anger that are being felt across the campus.

Penn State must do whatever it takes to fix these issues, a process that won’t be accomplished in any short amount of time. Because of the sensitive nature of the allegations and the suddenness with which events have occurred, football should be placed on the back burner of priorities.

Of course, the idea of forfeiting the season throws itself against two obvious counter-arguments, each equally viable. One, it seems to punish players rather than the administration responsible for the scandal.

Two, it may be best for the image of the Penn State football program to end with a strong season despite the setbacks and scandals.

On the first point, it’s impossible to argue that forfeiting the season seems a fair solution for Nittany Lions still eager to take the field. However, their season has already been disrupted, at least image-wise, beyond repair. Unfortunately, the team became just one part of a troubled university system as the depth of the scandal was revealed throughout the week. Separation between different teams and departments has disappeared.

The NCAA should take some initiative and grant at least upperclassmen the ability to transfer to other schools without penalty, as it did with the University of Southern California after the school was sanctioned in 2010.

On the second point, forfeiting could actually go a long way toward preserving the image of Penn State and the Big Ten Conference as a whole. Any success, any bowl game the team could achieve, will be tainted by the scandal. Should the team continue to play, especially if it places highly, it could seem cavalier on the part of both the Penn State program and the Big Ten Conference. At this point, officials in the Big Ten must already be questioning, in light of the scandal, how it would appear if the school were celebrated or rewarded, regardless of performance. Postponing further play until next season and starting the football schedule fresh avoids these problems on both ends.

Perhaps, more than anything, is the fact that these feelings, among campus fans, among Penn State and the Big Ten administration, won’t change by next week’s game at Ohio State. Or by the Wisconsin game the week after.

By forfeiting the remainder of the season, Penn State would be able to begin the process of recovering from a terrible situation that involved members of the administrative and athletic departments.

And, through a forfeit, the university can focus on addressing what issues it can immediately and start looking ahead to the future.

It’s not the only solution. In many ways, it’s not even the most fair. But among unprecedented uproar in college football, the DN stands by the viability of forfeiting the remainder of the season.

Read more here: http://www.dailynebraskan.com/opinion/staff-penn-state-should-consider-forfeiting-remainder-of-season-1.2669352
Copyright 2026 Daily Nebraskan