Joe Paterno had a vision, a dream with the potential to vastly change the landscape of college football.
It was an idea he backed passionately and had thought through again and again behind those iconic spectacles.
When he took over as Athletic Director at Penn State in the spring of 1980, the wheels of his plan had already been set in motion.
“Joe Paterno, from the time he became head coach, was a defender of eastern football,” said Fran Fisher, former Penn State football radio announcer. “He constantly reminded people that eastern football was a good football arrangement, and good football was played there.”
Paterno so strongly believed in the talent and tradition of college athletics, especially football in the East, he wanted to create an all-sports conference including all the storied schools in the region.
Now, after Pittsburgh and Syracuse signed on to become members of the Atlantic Coast Conference on Sept. 18, the eastern teams Paterno originally had in mind are now affiliated with a handful of different conferences.
But before each school had gone its separate way, Paterno envisioned Pitt, Syracuse, Boston College, West Virginia, Temple and Maryland — to name a few — all competing with one another in one conference.
“I’ve been trying since day one to try to get a couple of those schools, one of those schools or some other school in the East in the Big Ten, because I think there’s a tremendous market for recruiting and football in the area that the schools are moving into,” Paterno said. “Fifty million people live in the areas that we’re talking about, an awful lot of kids playing football and all sports.”
Paterno, who has always tried to blend athletics and academics, also wanted his eastern conference to uphold the high academic standards he had established at Penn State.
Although his eastern conference never became more than just a dream, Paterno has continued to stress the importance of athletics. His teams are consistently among the top teams in the country in graduation rate, and in 2010, Paterno’s players were second only to Northwestern in the Big Ten.
Before the Lions joined the Big Ten in 1990 and began playing football in the conference 1993, Penn State had competed as an independent in football for all but one year. The Lions were a part of the Pennsylvania Intercollegiate Football Association in 1891. But before Paterno’s program joined the Big Ten, there was constant chatter about teaming up the other prestigious programs in the region.
And Penn State historian Lou Prato said there were a variety of reasons why Paterno wanted to bring those teams together.
Prato said Paterno had felt disrespected when each of the coaches’ undefeated squads — 1968, 1969 and 1973 — hadn’t been named national champions. Playing in a conference with other high-caliber teams would have bolstered the Lions chances at a national title.
Geographically, Prato said it made more sense for the Lions to play eastern teams than most of the teams they currently compete against in the Big Ten from the Midwest.
“We don’t have a natural rivalry,” Prato said.
Penn State first played Pitt in 1893, and the two programs faced off every year after that from 1900-31 and from 1935-92.
It was a perfect match.
Unfortunately for Paterno, not everybody was on board.
Syracuse and Boston College had become founding members of the Big East basketball conference
in 1979, and Pitt turned down Paterno’s proposition to join the Orange and Eagles in 1982.
With three of the major players out, Paterno’s vision had fallen through.
Prato said it’s unclear why other schools defied Paterno and his eastern conference.
“It left a lot of bad blood,” Prato said.
However, Paterno went on to bring national championships to Happy Valley in 1982 and 1986 as an independent program before joining the Big Ten.
And while he once wanted to join up with Pitt and Syracuse, Paterno said he wishes the best for both programs in their new endeavors.
“They’re old friends and old competitors against us,” Paterno said. “And a lot of those guys who are associated with those programs, I literally grew up with. So I don’t have any compunctions in wishing them well.”
Paterno said he doesn’t know where the Big Ten will end up in the future, and he added there may be speculation Penn State should look into the possibilities of another conference.
Still, as programs like TCU and Texas A&M have chosen to realign with different conferences, Paterno hasn’t ruled out pulling eastern schools further into the national spotlight.
“Now that [Pitt and Syracuse] are out of it, ‘Why don’t we take a look at Rutgers?’ ” Paterno said. “And take a look at somebody that we can bring in from the East so that the Big Ten doesn’t end in State College.”
However, if the Big Ten were to welcome another school from the East, it would have to consider the financial implications of the addition.
That is because the Big Ten is the only conference that equally distributes its revenue earned through bowl appearances and its TV network amongst all its schools.
In 2010, each school received $22.6 million no matter its record or finish in the standings.
Former Big East commissioner Mike Tranghese said on WFAN Radio in New York on Sept. 19 that the Big Ten would want to add a school that would pull in viewers from a new area if it expanded.
And he said a school like Rutgers wouldn’t have enough of a pull in the New York City market, and thus wouldn’t contribute enough to the conference financially.
“You have less mouths to feed, easier to run,” said Tranghese, who mentioned Notre Dame as a sensible candidate. “You add people when you add value. You just don’t add numbers.”
Paterno went on to serve as Penn State’s Athletic Director for just two seasons. Many have said the coach found it difficult to balance coaching football while running the show for the entire athletics program.
And while Paterno’s dream of uniting the East to prove its teams could run with traditional powers in the SEC and Big Ten, Prato said what Paterno had in mind was well ahead of the time.
“In essence, Joe Paterno tried to do something for eastern football and Penn State in the 1980s that did not succeed because of the typical political in fighting that goes in every walk of life,” Prato said. “He shook up college football with what he did. He was a pioneer.”