Researchers study health effects of World Trade Center dust

By Kristine Rosette Enerio

Paul Lioy, director of Exposure Science at the Environmental and Occupational Health Sciences Institute (EOHSI) at Rutgers U., still feels proud after 10 years of the mass cooperation that drew the country together after the Sept. 11 attacks.

Although he was not a rescue worker, he experienced some of that synergy when it came to his research — analyzing dust particles from the fallen World Trade Center.

In a matter of days, Lioy assembled his first team of researchers when a number of agencies asked if he could collect dust immediately after the attacks.

“As soon as some my colleagues knew I had samples, I had people…saying ‘Paul, send us what you got.’ I said, ‘I have no money’ and they said, ‘Debt doesn’t matter. We don’t care about the money. It was about doing work,'” he said.

To Lioy, the feeling was very gratifying.

“One of the best things about academics in the United States is the fact that if you know people and you know how to work together, you can develop collaborative teams, and you can get things done,” he said.

The effort began as a volunteer effort, comprised of Lioy and a few of his colleagues at EOHSI, but it expanded to include researchers from around the nation.

“We were very concerned at that point because there were a mass amount of materials and we were wondering what was in it. … So we decided to … analyze the entire dust, not make any judgments beforehand as what to analyze and what not to analyze,” he said.

After inspecting the samples, the team found that some of the major components included cement, cellulose from destroyed paper, some asbestos and polycyclic automatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) or potent atmospheric pollutants that are formed by incomplete combustion of carbon-containing fuels.

But one of the more damaging substances found was fiberglass and other glass particles, Lioy said.

“[There were] 110 stories and two buildings of glass that just basically fell apart, plus interior glass,” he said. “And it didn’t fall apart and look like broken glass. It became into these little daggers of dust fiber. It was pretty intense.”

In essence, the dust was made up of the components of a modern building, which Lioy found both remarkable and frightening.

“It was so unusual because [when] you think of building demolition, you don’t think of a demolished building being pulverized to dust,” he said.

Other than the material make-up of the samples, the size of the particles found in the dust also proved to be unusual.

While humans normally breath particles in every day, Lioy said they are usually very fine particles and are regulated due to long-term consequences for cardiovascular and respiratory disease.

“But this was different. These were very, very large particles,” he said. “We didn’t even have name for it so we called it ‘super coarse particles’ because they were bigger than what we normally collect in the environment.”

Fine to coarse particles range from .1 to 10 micrometers in diameter, he said. But the particles they observed ranged from 10 to hundreds of micrometers in diameter.

“Under normal circumstances, you wouldn’t think of that being a health concerns but then you put it together and think ‘large quantities of it, inhaled’ … plus the fact it had all these fibers in it,” he said. “And those fibers also would tend to be like daggers going out into the lungs.”

Due to the lack of proper measuring equipment, one element that initial 9/11 material collectors could not account for was gas from the burning fuel of the jet planes.

Lioy believes that they will never know the true amount of gas and other dangerous fuel materials that were expelled that day.

“When you are dealing with a catastrophic event in real life, 99 percent of the time you don’t have the measurement devices available,” he said. “The only thing you have sometimes are people with experience with the event, and 9/11 caught us 100 percent off guard cause no one ever had to deal with it before.”

But the adverse health affects due to dust inhalation were thoroughly researched and recorded.

Studies done at the University and other institutions have shown there is persistent asthma in about 27 percent of the rescue workers, Lioy said. Thirty to 40 percent have had incidents of long-term sinusitis.

It is also likely that workers swallowed the dust materials in addition to inhaling them, which Lioy said led to instances of gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD).

“Another thing that’s very important is that the people with the highest level of effect and longer-lasting effect are ones who got there early and were exposed to the dust as it was being generated in the first few hours,” he said.

Still, Lioy said dangerous dust particles and long-term health affects were far from peoples’ minds that day, which may have added to the danger.

“We didn’t start making the connection as quickly as we should,” he said. “Within the first week it was clear that something was happening because people began to talk about a cough then it became coined ‘the World Trade Center cough.'”

Because relief effort and rescuing victims were the main areas of focus after the 9/11 attacks, precautions to protect the rescuers were not adequate.

“There were respirators that were put there but respirators weren’t fitted to people,” he said. “[They did] not really made it mandatory to get the respirators on because there were so many agencies in charge or not in charge.”

Since President Barack Obama signed the 9/11 Health Bill — which provides $4.3 billion over five years for health coverage to 9/11 rescue workers — in January, research work like Lioy’s had become useful.

But he refuses to develop personal feelings on the issue.

“I try not to politicize things because it’s unfair to anyone,” he said. “All I can do is make sure when I do my work I give honest answers and give the best info I have possible.”

Overall Lioy said he is pleased with the approach his team took and believes it was the most complete assessment of the World Trade Center dust that could be made.

He published experiences last year in his book titled, “Dust: The Inside Story of its Role in the September 11th Aftermath” and said writing it was a cathartic.

Still, Lioy wishes cohesiveness of post-9/11 had stuck around.

“[I] feel just as proud of people, how they came together at the time,” he said. “I think the thing that disappoints me is how we’ve lost some of that [as a country] over the last ten years. It actually came together and it didn’t stay together.”

Read more here: http://www.dailytargum.com/in-focus/researchers-study-health-effects-of-world-trade-center-dust-1.2623199
Copyright 2026 Daily Targum