Movie review: ‘Idiot’ surprisingly smart

By Nick Webster

Movie review: ‘Idiot’ surprisingly smart

“I try to do good, but I just screw up.”

Those are the words of Ned, a “bio-dynamic” New York farmer played by Paul Rudd in “Our Idiot Brother,” a Sundance Film Festival comedy recently released in theaters.

In the opening scene, while selling produce at a local farmer’s market, a uniformed police officer confronts Ned and asks where he can score some cannabis. Moved by the officer’s reasoning for needing the drug, Ned gives him a bag for free. The officer then insists on paying, and upon finally accepting the cash, Ned is arrested and sent to prison.

The scene sets the tone for the rest of the film. It’s a comedy about a man who possesses a huge heart, but lacks the motivation and intelligence to make his own decisions. Due to this unfortunate combination, Ned is consistently put into awkward situations by the people who love him.

All three of Ned’s sisters (Elizabeth Banks, Zooey Deschanel and Emily Mortimer), along with their love interests (Adam Scott, Rashida Jones and Steve Coogan), force him to spill secrets, and in the aftermath scapegoat Ned for the problems in their relationships. The only person he really feels he can talk to is his parole officer, who eventually is forced to turn his back as well.

Along with a wardrobe straight out of 1995, Rudd’s portrayal of Ned will leave audiences consistently blurting out the phrase “what an idiot.” Despite his flaws, Ned is impossible to hate. All he really wants in life is to play a game of charades with his family once a week and to play fetch with his labrador retriever, Willy Nelson.

Watching the film, it feels like the role was written specifically with Rudd in mind. He’s not the cookie cutter character we’ve seen over and over again in “I Love You, Man,” “Role Models” and “Knocked Up.” Think Jeff Spicoli with the heart and charm of Forrest Gump.

Despite the great cast, the film sometimes suffers from being uneven. It goes from laugh-out-loud funny to heavy and sad in an instant. In one particular scene, Ned is searching the town for his lost dog. While running through the streets, he repeatedly yells out “Willy Nelson.” In any other situation, a pothead running through the streets repeating Nelson’s name over and over would be pretty funny, and there were a few laughs in the audience.

The problem lies in the fact that during this scene, we’re supposed to feel sympathy for Ned, and instead, we’re given something to laugh about. It’s a problem that plagues the entire film. The film’s end is rather cliché and abrupt, but still altogether sweet.


VERDICT:

While it doesn’t offer any memorable one-liners to quote, “Our Idiot Brother” will leave audiences laughing throughout. Like its lead character, the film is hard to hate, despite its flaws. 4/5 stars.

Read more here: http://www.kaleo.org/features/idiot-surprisingly-smart-1.2623369
Copyright 2026 Ka Leo O Hawaii