Big Ten players, official talk about possibility of paying players

By Joe McIntyre

Scholarship football players at Division I schools walk a tightrope between a suffering student and a high-profile celebrity athlete.

They tilt to the right and they’re a half-inch away from athletic stardom. They’ve already got the fans and much of their expenses are paid for. They’re living what the thousands of white-clad fans in Beaver Stadium dream of when they go through Gate A.

But they lean to the left, and they’re just like the rest of the thousands of students — struggling to pay for the daily expenses of a college student and up late at night studying for a biology exam.

But the scholarship pays for it all, doesn’t it?

Well, except for the gas, the car, the food delivery, the shirts, the shoes. The entertainment, the phone bill, the extraneous costs.

“We do a lot for football. We do a lot for college football,” Purdue safety Albert Evans said at Big Ten Media Days in July. “We do a lot for the university. At the same time, sometimes a scholarship check doesn’t cover it.”

It can all be solved by getting a job, though, pulling in a little extra cash to pay for it all.

But when?

Between a full class load, hours of practice, film study, book study, weight training, health recovery time, there are simply too few hours in the day for a football player to be able to handle a job, Evans said.

“It’d be too overwhelming for student athletes,” Northwestern’s Al Netter said. “I know personally for me as an offensive lineman, the money I’m given for a scholarship, I don’t even have enough money to fill all my food needs for a month.”

“For offensive and defensive linemen, it’s tough because you’re expected to keep weight or gain weight. So I think it puts people in a tough position.”

No more problems

There’s Jim Tressel, Terrelle Pryor and Ohio State. There’s Cam Newton, his father and Auburn. There’s Miami, Nevin Shapiro and countless Hurricanes players.

During the past few years, the book of college football reads more like Bernie Madoff’s biography than a tale of athletic attainment.

It’s the glory of money that tractor-beams the athletes.

“I know it’s different for some guys, but some guys just don’t have a lot of money and it’s tough on them,” Netter said. “There’s a lot of temptation in college football when someone’s holding a check in front of you, and you have no money in your account. What are you going to do?”

It’s easy to criticize players like Pryor and Newton for taking the benefits, but if a non-student athlete were offered the same deal and took it, there would be no consequences.

There are no NCAA rules prohibiting an English major from getting some free ink. There are no laws saying professors can’t pay for the lunch of one of their students.

But that’s blasphemy in the church of the NCAA.

Even if college athletes were to get a salary, would it be enough to cure college football’s ailments?

“I think a lot of times you make a change and you get rid of some problems, but some things we didn’t think of pop up,” Big Ten director of officiating Bill Carollo said.

“People always want more and they want it better and they want it faster. So there are probably some things that even the smartest people haven’t even thought about. So problems will continue.”

Creating resentment

Most outsiders may look at the “free” rides student-athletes get and believe those players get enough already.

The tuition for an in-state student at Penn State is $15,124. An out-of-stater forks over $27,206 to attend.

While most students will be stuck with thousands upon thousands of dollars of debt after graduating or put the load on their parents, full scholarship athletes will leave their school without owing a dime.

If athletes were to earn money for practicing and playing games on top of the full-rides they already receive, Evans said it could create even more of a disconnect between the athlete and traditional student.

“I think the student body might resent it a lot, but at the same time, I feel like if they saw what we did and went through what we did, they would understand that these guys put in a lot of work,” Evans said.

And if the players eventually are given some compensation for their contributions to the universities, most said they wouldn’t expect anything exorbitant.

Minimum wage for the hours they put in on the practice field, the weight room and the stadium is enough, they said. Just some cash to put in their pockets to treat themselves to a pizza every once in a while or a coffee before an 8 a.m. class.

Carollo believes, in the future, it may be possible to offer a financial benefit on the back end after graduation if student-athletes finish their degree in good faith.

It’s important to tie it to education, he said, because doing that assures graduating with a degree comes before athletics.

“I think in America, you get paid for everything you contribute, what you’re worth,” Carollo said.

“I think they’ll find the common ground. There’s a right answer for the athletes. It’s an interesting time because it’s a big business. The athletes are producing big revenues for football. They’ll figure it out.”

Timetable

It’s only a matter of time.

For the 2009 season, Penn State football took in $70,208,584 in revenue, making $50,427,645 in profit, according to the Forbes’ SportsMoney blog.

Though a majority of that money funds sports that don’t receive income, players still wonder where the millions they’re primarily responsible for bringing in actually go.

“The reality of the situation is the sports that bring in money, they bring in money and other sports don’t,” Wisconsin wide receiver Nick Toon said. “It’s no different than in the real world. Who knows? But that’s something that they need to look into.”

Big Ten commissioner Jim Delany is examining the possibility, Carollo said. He thinks there’s going to be improvement, but whether it changes the problems surrounding college football?

Who knows?

“I think that there’s a place for it,” Carollo said. “Do [football players] contribute to the university? Yes. Do they help drive revenue? Absolutely.”

“They put their lives and their health on the line and pressure to help and be successful there. We think they’re [eventually going to be] getting compensated, and I think that if you tie it to education, that may be a solution.”

Read more here: http://www.collegian.psu.edu/archive/2011/09/09/big_ten_players_official_talk_about_possibility_of_paying_players.aspx
Copyright 2026 Daily Collegian