DREAM Act and its potential ramifications

By Karlanna Lewis

In 2010 the DREAM Act–an acronym for Development Relief and Education for Alien Minors Act–failed the vote in the Senate by 5 votes. For many undocumented students in Florida, a state with a heavy immigrant population, this act has released a lot of emotions Julio Calderas, an undocumented student who came to the US from Honduras is studying at Miami-Dade College. Calderas said most people don’t know that the DREAM act was proposed by a Republican.

“The idea was to provide in-state tuition and citizenship to undocumented students,” said Calderas. “They’ve reintroduced it every year since 2001. In 2007 it was introduced and it didn’t pass. Then the idea of having statewide DREAM Acts came out. Texas was the first state to pass the DREAM act.”

Though statewide DREAM Acts are a positive step for immigrant students, they don’t provide the full benefits that a piece of national legislation could provide.

“State DREAM Acts don’t provide legal status; they just provide in-state tuition,” said Calderas. “You must have graduated from a high school and gone to school at least three years in the state.”

During the ten-year lifetime of the DREAM Act, certain senators and representatives have been strong advocates for the cause, according to an undocumented Costa Rican student at Polk State College–Mayra Hidalgo.

“Senator Dick Durbin has been our champion from the beginning,” said Hidalgo. “The DREAM Act is a fitting name, not only because it’s an acronym, but because the act represents us having access to achieving out dreams of being college graduates and professionals in this country.”

A clause in the DREAM Act allows for military-minded undocumented students to enter defensive service for two years. Promoters of the DREAM Act decided to attempt to pass it as an amendment to a military bill this year.

“The Defense Bill has passed the past 5 years,” said Calderas. “They put [the DREAM Act] as an amendment and they thought it was going to pass, and it failed. That’s when we started campaigning. It wasn’t until December the 18th that it came up to vote, and it failed once again. People always say Democrats support the DREAM Act, and we failed because of five Democrats who didn’t vote for it. If we would have had all the Democrats’ votes and the few Republicans’ that we got, right now we would have the DREAM Act.”

The failure of the DREAM Act in December sent many back to their native countries; many of these students may have spent so little time in their native countries that they don’t even remember it. Diego Sanchez, an Argentinean studying psychology and global leadership at St. Thomas University, said this has caused cultural gap because many of these students know relatively little about their “native culture.”

“In December a lot of students just decided to go back to their country,” said Sanchez. “You have students who have been here since they were two or three years old. They don’t know their country and they don’t speak the language, so it’s really hard. By the time students do know they can apply they probably will have already started flunking in school. It happened to me in my senior year of high school. I was a straight-A student and I stopped caring because I thought I was just going back to my country. It really dis-empowers [sic] you. A lot of [undocumented students] will drop out, join gangs–even students who want to join the military, they can’t even do that–and they’re just going to go back to their country. It’s a lot of wasted talent.”

Despite most Americans being immigrants at some point in their lives or along their family tree, arguments against the DREAM Act, according to Sanchez, are born of fear of immigration.

“Some conservatives would say the DREAM Act is an amnesty because it would allow people to keep asking for their parents, their cousins, whenever they get their papers,” said Sanchez. “It’s not true because it’s 10 years to become a citizen; 6 years to get your residency. In order to petition for someone you need to be a citizen. They say it will create a mass amnesty but in reality it really won’t. They’re also saying that [undocumented students] are going to take a lot of benefits from their own kids, and we’re really not asking for benefits, we’re just asking to be treated the same.”

Another part of the opposition to the DREAM Act comes from a fear of competition said Calderas.

“The argument against it is that students are going to take the places of other Americans,” said Calderas. “People are afraid of competition. There are a lot of brilliant students out there who are undocumented and they never made it to college.”

When the DREAM Act didn’t pass, supporters began lobbying for a smaller measure: the In-State Tuition Bill. Though many undocumented students have lived in Florida for most of their lives, they still have to pay seemingly endless out-of-state tuition rates.

“The In-State Tuition Bill, some call it the California DREAM Act, the Illinois DREAM Act–it’s not the same thing,” said Sanchez. “It allows undocumented students to pay the same amount as in-state students. We have to pay 3 or 4 times as much as everyone else, and that’s why we don’t go to college. We don’t even get financial aid. The California DREAM Act goes even further, and it allows undocumented students to get some financial aid. In Florida we’ve had this going on for a couple years, but we were never able to organize it. Because we have an anti-immigration law like Arizona, the DREAM Act is nowhere near getting passed.”

As in passing any legislation, the first step is bringing the issue to the attention of politicians.

“We’re just starting to organize now for the In-State Tuition Bill, and we spoke to Representatives Bullard and Shiplin,” said Sanchez. “Shiplin said it was going to be worthless because we didn’t have the votes. It’s really hard in a Republican majority like we have right now. We’re at the defensive. After speaking to Shiplin–he’s a Democrat, but he has a lot of close ties with a lot of Republicans–we’re trying to contact them now, people like the majority leader. If we can convince them–we’re not going to lose anything.”

Many avenues are available for allies of DREAM Act students to lobby for the cause. In Tallahassee, the FSU organization Advocates for Immigrant and Refugee Rights (AIRR) is working to make the dream a reality. Students Working for Equal Rights is another group that works in the Florida Youth Network to educate people about the DREAM Act and the struggles some adolescents and young adults have when it comes to higher education.

Many Floridian students have personal stakes in the future of the DREAM Act.

“I’ve been undocumented for the majority of my life,” said Hidalgo. “The only time I was not undocumented was the first 6 months of my life in Costa Rica before I was brought to the U.S. I’ve worked hard, done everything I’ve needed to do as a student, but I’m lacking a piece of paper to move forward with my college career and life. The DREAM Act students. or ‘dreamers’ as we like to call ourselves, will have to keep waiting. We’ll continue fighting for this bill because it’s our only hope. We cannot even fathom returning to a country most of us do not remember. The U.S. is our home.”

Read more here: http://www.fsunews.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20110814/FSVIEW/110814004
Copyright 2026 FSView & Florida Flambeau