Column: ‘On Stranger Tides’ unnecessary, yet enjoyable

By Christian Law

If modern people actually spent days riding a sailboat while drunk off of rum, they would be considered a lunatic (albeit a stylish one).  Yet leave it to Disney to glorify the life of a pirate, all in the form of a children’s ride at Disney World.Several hundred million dollars, worldwide popularity and a few sequels later, the “Pirates of the Caribbean” series has become one of Disney’s most successful franchises.

The original trilogy was creative and perfectly cast, featuring Johnny Depp, Orlando Bloom and Keira Knightley in roles that added many years to their careers.  The plots, with top-notch action and snappy dialogue, were always fun to follow.  At the conclusion of the third film, “At World’s End,” the characters went off on their separate ways, leaving the series with a dignified end.

And then Disney announced that “Pirates” would be back with a fourth installment.

Fans were split, facing either excitement or disdain at the decision to wring more money out of a profitable series.  Released May 20, “On Stranger Tides” is destined to fuel that split.

For the fourth outing, Captain Jack Sparrow (Depp) finds himself in London, searching for an imposter who is using his name to recruit pirates to find the Fountain of Youth. Sparrow finds the fake Jack Sparrow to be former flame Angelica (Penelope Cruz), the enchanting daughter of famously evil pirate Blackbeard (Ian McShane).  Meanwhile, Sparrow’s old foe Barbossa (Geoffrey Rush) is also on his tail, with both ships racing to find the Fountain first.

Along the way there are mutinies, encounters with terrifying mermaids and other spectacles that live up to the “Pirates” name.  The writing is sharp and witty, allowing Depp to work his comedic muscle alongside Rush to create the funniest movie of the series.  The plot is farfetched but still a blast, and the new characters are all used well and keep the action fresh.

Yet despite all of this, something doesn’t sit quite right.

Maybe it’s the lack of fellow leads Bloom and Knightley, whose chemistry made the first three films so much fun to watch.  Or maybe it’s the time lapse that gave fans time to grow up and out of touch with their favorite pirates.  All of these small problems build to create a glaring issue with “On Stranger Tides”: the questionable necessity of the film.

Yes, the movie is fun and fans will find new scenes and characters to love.  But after ending the successful trilogy in a great way, it seems like this fourth film was tacked on for money rather than for actual love of the series.  Instead of feeling like a true sequel in the series, “On Stranger Tides” feels more like a well-done straight-to-DVD cash in.

Yet this doesn’t result in a bad movie.  “Pirates” newbie director Rob Marshall gives the action more noise and flash than before, and the scene involving the capture of a mermaid deserves a spot in the canon of top “Pirates” scenes.  However, compared to the original trilogy, the drop in cinematic quality is apparent and disheartening for the future of the series (as of right now, there are at least two more films planned).

Despite this shortcoming, the cast involved makes the film highly enjoyable.  The romance between Depp and Cruz sizzles and is often quite hilarious.  Rush’s portrayal of Barbossa is perfect, but McShane’s Blackbeard steals the show.  The rivalry between Barbossa and Blackbeard leads to one of the most entertaining conclusions of the series.

Overall, “On Stranger Tides” is an entertaining start to the mindless summer film season.  Although it stands on its own as a decent action romp, it’s as unnecessary an addition to the “Pirates” series as an ego in a church choir.  Fans will find plenty to love, but the film won’t do anything to sway new viewers.

Hopefully the fifth film can do something that will stand as a terrific “Pirates” movie rather than a ho-hum summer film. Savvy?

—

Speakeasy Rating: B-

“Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides”

Starring Johnny Depp, Geoffrey Rush, Penelope Cruz, Ian McShane

Rated PG-13 for intense sequences of action/adventure violence, some frightening images, sensuality and innuendo.

Read more here: http://speakeasymag.com/entertainment/on-stranger-tides-unnecessary-yet-enjoyable/
Copyright 2026 The Speakeasy