We are not all Americans, at least not according to some Republicans.
Legislation proposed last month by Republican Sens. Rand Paul of Kentucky and David Vitter of Louisiana aims to close what they call the birthright citizenship loophole. The 14th Amendment established the birthright citizenship and states, “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside.”
This amendment means children born in the United States, no matter the citizenship status of their parents, are considered American citizens.
But Paul and Vitter hope to change that.
In an article Vitter published through CNN, he wrote, “I believe the policy of birthright citizenship is incompatible with both the text and the legislative history of the 14th Amendment, which is why I recently introduced legislation so that a person born in the United States to illegal immigrants does not automatically gain citizenship unless at least one parent is a legal citizen, a lawful permanent resident (green card holder) or an active member of the Armed Forces.”
According to a study published by the Pew Hispanic Center, 8 percent of U.S. births in 2008 were to unauthorized immigrants.
The study also stated in 2009, about four million U.S. born children under the age of 18 residing in the U.S. had unauthorized immigrant parents.
And now, these children’s futures are in jeopardy.
If the legislation passes, then children born in America to unauthorized parents will no longer be considered Americans.
They will be forced to go through the long process of obtaining green cards or becoming naturalized citizens.
If not, they risk being deported to their parents’ native country.
These children, who were born in America and formerly considered part of an American society will be displaced. If they do not belong in America, where do they belong?
Certainly not in a foreign country where they have no allegiance, and which they have possibly never even visited.
Alongside Vitter’s article on CNN, Rep. Michael Honda of California, a Democrat who opposes this legislation, published another.
Honda wrote, “Denying citizenship to persons born in the United States who do not meet this new Republican interpretation could produce tens of thousands of people with undeterminated nationality each year and lead to a bureaucratic nightmare.”
He also wrote, according to a study by UCLA professor Raul Hinojosa-Ojeda, deportation plans of America’s undocumented immigrants would cost the U.S. $2.6 trillion during the next 10 years, while embracing comprehensive immigration reform would add $1.5 trillion.
Closing the birthright citizenship loophole would obviously not be the most cost effective solution to America’s immigrant population.
If closing this loophole could be so detrimental to America’s already struggling economy, why are Republicans pushing to make it happen?
This issue raises ethical concerns, not just financial concerns.
What would happen to the millions of people born on U.S. soil to unauthorized immigrant parents if they no longer belonged anywhere? This fight is not over yet. This legislation still has to pass votes in both the Congress and Senate.
Democrats that oppose this solution will have their opportunity to make sure it does not pass the vote, but America can not rely on them alone.
All Americans need to make their stand.
The government cannot be allowed to tell children born in this country that they are not Americans.
Write letters to state representatives, sign a petition, start a protest if that’s what it takes to stop the government from denying a person their right to call themselves American.
America may have a problem with the rising numbers of illegal immigrants, but redefining the 14th Amendment is not the solution.