In a press release posted on Friday, Facebook announced an expectation to start filing public financial reports before mid-2012, which has created a buzz among financial investors and the media.
Facebook, which is a privately held company, will have to file public financial reports as a result of reaching 500 investors, a law set out by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.
The public financial reports will mean Facebook’s revenue sources will be disclosed, such as how much it makes from advertisements or exchanging information with third parties.
Facebook’s privacy policy, last updated in October, states that personal, identifiable information – name, address, etc. – is not shared with third-party companies unless authorized by the user, but characteristic information – likes, interests, etc. – may be shared with advertisers.
This is why side ads on Facebook pages are sometimes concurrent with the pages or words on profiles.
One way to increase privacy is through customizable privacy settings and not posting content for “everyone” to see.
Jill McCullough, an instructor in the College of Business Administration at Youngstown State U., said Facebook users could actually be more protected – from a privacy standpoint – because the company will be more accountable for its actions when its revenue sources become available for public consumption.
Users may be more protected because they can more easily find out what companies Facebook receives money from in exchange for private information.
The SEC law is meant to protect investors from a company that could potentially hide important financial information.
The press release also announced $1.5 billion in direct investments at a valuation of about $50 billion.
Valuation is the estimation of a company’s market value for investors and potential investors and comes from an initial public offering that feels the financial market for how much big investors are willing to put into a company.
Many sources began questioning this exuberant valuation as soon as it was announced.
In an article in Time magazine, Stephen Gandel questioned the valuation on the basis that the Goldman Sachs Group, a global investment firm, provided the valuation, then invested $500,000 into Facebook with Digital Sky Technologies and an additional $1 billion in a collection from some of Goldman Sachs’ non-U.S.
clients.
McCullough said it’s harder to valuate a technology company like Facebook because its revenue is based on less static factors than companies that produce an object that has a set price like clothing or food. She compared the valuation to Facebook’s 500,000 members, each being worth $100 each year they maintain an account. It’s believed that Facebook makes a lot less per member.
As a private company, Facebook owners and primary investors are able to maintain control of the company’s shares and select who can or cannot buy and sell those shares. Once it reaches 500 investors and begins filing public financial reports,
Facebook investors can choose to sit on their shares or begin trading publicly.
It’s reported that Mark Zuckerberg has expressed an interest to remain a private company for as long as he can, but it is unknown if the recent market around Facebook will influence his view.
McCullough said an advantage to bringing Facebook public is that Zuckerberg and investors can potentially make a “boatload” of money, but lose a lot of privacy and some control, which does not mesh with the personality Zuckerberg has developed in the media.
She said other problems experienced when companies go public is pressure by shareholders.
Pressure by shareholders could potentially lead to problems if the company is not making money right away and investors want the company to switch to a model that will make more money sooner. While however unlikely, this could equate to subscription fees or a similar money-making model.