Democratic Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand of New York announced last week that she would be leading the charge to reform Senate rules and procedure, chief among which is the way the filibuster has come to be used today.
When most people think of the filibuster, they perhaps conjure the image of Jimmy Stewart in Frank Capra’s classic 1939 film “Mr. Smith Goes to Washington,” wherein Stewart played freshman Senator Jefferson Smith who during the film’s climax conducts a filibuster to delay a corrupt bill and prove his innocence on trumped-up charges.
The filibuster—a term derived from the Dutch word for “pirate”—is an arcane obstructionist tool in which a senator can prevent a measure from being brought to a vote by extending the debate indefinitely. This is usually done by simply ranting on the Senate floor for hours on end.
A filibuster can only be defeated by invoking cloture—a measure that will bring the debate on a bill to a close, but requires 60 votes to invoke. Therefore, any time a senator decides to filibuster a bill, 60 votes will be required to even get the bill through the debate and on to the floor for an actual vote.
Originally, the Senate could end debate on a bill by what was known as the “Previous Question Motion,” whereby a simple majority (today would be 51 out of 100) could bring the bill to the floor for a vote—a rule the House of Representatives still currently uses. But at the urging of Vice President Aaron Burr, the provision was eventually dropped in 1806, leaving the potential open for a filibuster.
When the “Previous Question Motion” was dropped, the Senate did not replace it with any procedure to end debate, so the filibuster became a theoretical option to delay or block a bill from being brought to a vote on the floor by never ending the debate and simply talking out the clock.
The first filibuster in the Senate occurred on March 11, 1841, when several senators ranted at length to object to the firing of Senate printers (staffers responsible for printing congressional records).
One of the strange rules about the filibuster is the senator or senators conducting it are not required to speak about the actual bill in question when extending debate, and are free to bluster at will on any topic. Louisiana Senator Huey P. Long was known to read to read the plays of Shakespeare and recipes for oyster dishes during his filibusters throughout the 1930s.
The longest and perhaps most infamous filibuster on record is that of South Carolina Senator Strom Thurmond, who railed for 24 hours and 18 minutes trying to block the Civil Rights Act of 1957. These days, however, long gone are the Jimmy Stewart-like speeches on the Senate floor.
Now all a senator has to do is simply threaten to filibuster a bill—even though they perhaps have no actual intention of ever ranting for hours on the floor. Once only used as a rare delaying tactic, the filibuster today has become standard operating procedure in the Senate to require a cloture motion for nearly every important bill.
This means that almost every significant piece of legislation must have the support of 60 senators to have a chance to ever be brought to a vote—when normally a bill only requires a simple majority of 51 to pass. Throughout the entire 19th century, fewer than two dozen filibusters were conducted in the Senate—and in the 1970s, approximately 20 per year.
But just in the past two years, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid has had to file for cloture to end a filibuster threat by Republicans 136 times. Using the filibuster as an obstructionist tool in this manner is antithetical to the original intent of the Senate as a deliberative body and grinds the legislative process to an infuriating halt.
Sen. Gillibrand is currently recommending returning to what is being referred to by some as the “Jimmy Stewart rule,” meaning that a senator cannot simply make an empty threat to filibuster, but must actually take to the floor and talk until he drops.
This idea makes some sense—considering the Senate has become the ultimate theater of the absurd, might as well add some flair for the theatrical. Independent Senator Bernie Sanders from Vermont recently did exactly this, when on Dec. 10, 2010, he harangued for eight and a half hours over the extension of the Bush-era tax cuts for the rich.
Perhaps the better solution would be to end the filibuster altogether and return to days of the “Previous Question Motion.”
Whatever the solution, the time for reform is now.