Surrounded by the success and glamour of your own fame, who cares enough to restrain you? This is a problem central to Gwyneth Paltrow’s latest film, Country Strong. Paltrow continues to expand her versatile and successful career as she showcases the singing talent hinted at during her cameo on Glee.
Paltrow plays the passionate yet weak Kelly Canter, a country superstar who used to take the world by storm, but now barely gets through a show after her early release from rehab. The tragic circumstances leading to her drinking problem put a major strain on her relationship with her husband and manager, James Canter (Tim McGraw). He insists that she is strong enough to get back on the road with a new tour, yet her lover, Alcoholics Anonymous sponsor and fellow country singer, Beau Hutton (Garrett Hedlund), disagrees vehemently and comes on the tour to keep watch over her. McGraw makes one other addition to the tour group: Chiles Stanton (Leighton Meester), the opening act, who is a former Miss Texas and nicknamed the “country Barbie.” This child star is the perfect antithesis to Paltrow – wholesome, seemingly naïve, and uncorrupted by fame while Paltrow battles the pressures of stardom.
Paltrow flawlessly transforms from actress to singer in this film, belting it out at the end with a stellar vocal performance. Tim McGraw lacks some of her transient abilities, as his character becomes convoluted. He is fantastically deplorable as the husband-manager who pushes his wife back into the limelight too quickly, disregarding her best interest at times. He is equally good and touching as the cuckolded husband who will always love his wife despite how many times she hurts him. Where McGraw fails is in making both personalities believable in one person, connecting the opposing facets.
This connection is something that Hedlund does well, as he plays both the sardonic, irreverent bar musician and the omnipresent, doe-eyed boy who loves Paltrow and hates to see her self-destructive slip-ups. Although his accent and mumbling can be hard to understand, Hedlund makes Beau the most likable character in the film.
The music is definitely the focus of this film (a warning to those who love Paltrow but detest country music), but it becomes mawkish at points when every character performs blatant autobiographical pieces. Beau best exemplifies this when mocking Meester’s first attempts at songwriting, particularly a piece titled “Honky Tonk Town.” Although the voices are impressive, most of the songs fall into the honky tonk category of country, lacking enough authenticity to satisfy true country fans but containing too much banjo to engage non-enthusiasts. Additionally, although Meester cutely steps into her role – the characterization of which is encapsulated by her unseasoned and paralyzing stage fright at a tiny bar venue – her character lacks enough depth to make Chiles believable next to Hutton’s well-developed persona. Interestingly enough, both Hutton and his character save Meester and Chiles from embarrassment in the film as he joins her on stage at the bar, renewing the crowd’s faith in her.
Although the plot of the film is arguably predictable, the subplot of Paltrow’s last, disastrous performance at Dallas (not shown in the film) gives Country Strong a great deal of depth and human connection, transforming it from a mild reflection on indulgent pop culture to an insightful adventure into the world of a woman who cannot control herself, despite her incredible talents. This aspect of the film is not employed nearly enough and Shana Feste – both director and writer of the film – should have given Paltrow more scenes with which to explore the most fascinating dimension of her character. Instead, Paltrow’s past demons are mentioned in passing and are only a frustrating taste of a truly moving storyline.