The BCS committee is a group of barbarians in search of noble Roman blood. Every year, a small contingent of would-be slaves acknowledges the need for resistance. This year’s freedom fighters came in the form of private university football team from Fort Worth, Texas.
Credit the Texas Christian Horned Frogs for being this year’s turd in the BCS’ punch bowl. Instead of perennial underdog favorite Boise State — who lost to Nevada to end its BCS busting hopes — the Horned Frogs went undefeated in big-time college football without a shot at the BCS national title. Last week, TCU won 21-19 over the Wisconsin Badgers in route to its first Rose Bowl and BCS bowl win since the system’s beginning in 1998. And like every other non-BCS conference school, TCU was penalized for its perfection by being left out of the only postseason college game that matters in football’s top division: tonight’s national championship game.
A majority of TCU’s peers around the college football world think the system needs to change so the Horned Frogs could have a shot at a national championship, but more on that later.
The Horned Frogs did what any team is expected to do to have any chance of playing for a national title in any sport: win. TCU beat each of the 12 Football Bowl Subdivision teams on the Horned Frogs’ 2010 schedule. Out of the seven major college football programs in the state of Texas — TCU, Texas, Texas Tech, Texas A&M, Houston, SMU and Baylor — the Horned Frogs came out on top when surely only their home-grown newspapermen gave them a chance to finish the season as they did.
TCU took on all-comers at home, away and on a neutral field, declaring with every touchdown scored and tackle made that no one would beat them — not this season. That kind of initiative, commitment and resolve matters in most sports, both college or professional.
Even in the most subjective sports — gymnastics, diving, figure skating or other sports dependent on judges — an undefeated regular season results in, at minimum, a shot at the championship.
Fans of college football have felt this should be their sports way for years. They are some of the most outspoken sports fans in America about the crass nature of their favorite sport, about the repugnant leadership that makes up the BCS and the mafia mentality of the commissioners of the BCS power conferences (ACC, Big East Big Ten, Big 12, Pac-10 and SEC).
Sports bloggers in general detest the BCS both in theory and in practice. Their vitriol for the system is transparent and viral across the Web.
Yahoo! sports columnists Dan Wetzel and New York Times college athletics reporter Pete Thamel have all but written out in crayon just how corrupt and greedy these BCS thieves are. In his book, “Death to the BCS,” Wetzel explained the financial basics of the bowl system, how a playoff system would be more lucrative and the inner workings of BCS committee — “the Cartel,” as he calls them.
But it was always going to take more than college football fan message boards, bloggers, pundits and reporters to make the radical change from the BCS system to a college football playoff to occur. It was always going to have start with the players and their union.
The National College Players Association released the results of a survey it conducted amongst the legions of college football players the NCAA claims are under its authoritative gaze.
The College Football Playoff Survey consisted of six questions. One such question asked, “Do you want a playoff in college football to determine the national champion?” to which 80.9 percent of college football players answered “yes.”
74.5 percent of college football players answered that they would prefer to participate in “playoff games that are played throughout several weeks immediately following the regular season.” Only 6.1 percent preferred a plus-one system, which — as the NCPA stated — would keep “the current BCS ranking system and add one more game to determine the national champion. The two teams that play in the national championship game would play only one game after the regular season.”
In a section at the end of the survey, in which the players to elaborate about their feelings about using a playoff system to determine a sole national champion, interesting comments were painted in ink. One anonymous player wrote, “That is horrible. We have allowed money to override the competitive spirit in college football and it is extremely sad… People know what is righteous and fair. Something MUST be done.”
Another player seemed to be looking for an option that is in the current bowl format’s best interest when he wrote, “A playoff system will eliminate the necessary criticism of the BCS, which favors power teams in a powerful conference weekly.”
One player was much less diplomatic in his approach: “LET’S CROWN A REAL CHAMPION!!!!!! MAKE THIS A NATIONAL MOVEMENT!”
Now it is all out on the table for everyone to see. Every faction that has a voice — whether it deserves to be heard — has had its say. But the BCS is not a democracy; it’s not republic either. It is a close-knit, co-op of empty suits who govern the most lucrative sport in all of amateur athletics like it is their own little Soviet Russia. A playoff is needed, if for no other reason than to make college football what it is at its core: American, where even the little guy gets a shot at the dream.
Wetzel said it best: “Death to the BCS.”