Experts question credibility of Excellence in Management Cup

By Noah Meyers

Although a recent study about economic efficiency in college athletics placed Ohio U. near the top of the nation, speculation has arisen about the study’s effectiveness and credibility.

The study, released annually by the Laboratory for the Study of Intercollegiate Athletics at Texas A&M U., ranks Football Bowl Subdivision (formerly Division I) universities based on a formula emphasizing conference and national championships.

Ohio finished 12th in the study. The Excellence in Management Cup, given to the top school every year, was awarded to Kent State U..

Despite the success, renowned economist Richard Vedder questions the significance of the study, and Faculty Senate Chairman Joseph McLaughlin doubts the relevance of the findings in relation to university budget issues.

“I like being recognized for economic efficiency in our athletic department,” said Jim Schaus, director of athletics. “It’s extremely important. The study exemplifies that some programs, including ours, are getting things out from what they’re putting in.”

Last year, OU finished 53rd in the study, with Utah State U. ranking first.

The formula calculated a school’s athletic success compared with total athletic operating expenses. The university’s number of national championships is multiplied by six and added to its number of conference championships. Each of these two figures is then divided by the number of sports each school offers.

Researchers then divide that number by the total athletic operating expenses for each university and the final number is multiplied by 100,000 to make it more manageable, said Dr. Shane Hudson, director of the laboratory at Texas A&M.

“We really wanted to give smaller schools a better chance in this one,” Hudson said. “Other studies don’t take into consideration that bigger schools are much more likely to win championships. They offer more sports and have more money to win with.”

Hudson added that the goal of the department’s study was to award athletic departments that can translate limited resources into championships.

Ohio finished third in the Mid-American Conference this year behind champion Kent State and Central Michigan, which finished fourth.

Despite OU being ranked higher than every school in several major conferences, the study does not take into consideration the opportunity cost of each school’s athletic budget.

An economic principle, opportunity cost means the value of the next best option. It is the relationship between scarcity and choice, and is important in determining that scarce resources are used efficiently, Vedder said.

“It’s a simple measure of cost-benefit analysis,” he said. “When a school loses over $15 million on athletics on a yearly basis, you have to start considering some of the other things it could do with that money.”

In a Board of Trustees meeting last Thursday, McLaughlin questioned the trustees’ spending habits. He directed some of his strongest criticism toward the athletic department.

“We understand the university has budget problems, but over the last two years, the intercollegiate athletics department has been given $2 million in revenue to fund its activity, while less money has been given to tenure and tenure-tracked faculty,” McLaughlin said in an interview.

Schaus said his department’s efforts help put a brand on the university, despite the criticism.

“I think we were on ESPN eight times last year,” Schaus said. “That helps someone identify just what this university is all about and who we are. If we expect to compete and keep growing as a school, we have to keep up that image.”

Last year, Ohio captured MAC championships in volleyball, men’s basketball, and field hockey. The football team made it to the MAC Championship game and the Little Caesars Pizza Bowl, and the basketball team garnered national recognition after upsetting No. 3 seed Georgetown in the NCAA Tournament.

Schaus highlighted the difficulties of balancing limited resources and expectations.

“It’s just like any other product,” he said. “When a person is weighing their different options, the exposure each has plays a huge role. Athletics gives a university that exposure.”

But McLaughlin said university enrollment figures do not back that claim.

“Last year we had the most successful year, performance-wise, in the 14 years I’ve been a faculty member here at Ohio University, yet we’ve actually noticed a dip in applications. It was actually a struggle to meet our goals,” McLaughlin said.

Excessive spending on athletics has also been blamed on mid-major schools’ quests to be “the next Boise State” – that is, spending enough money to one day be recognized on a national level in sports such as football and basketball.

“Schools like Ohio are looking to catch lightning in a bottle,” said Dr. David Ridpath, assistant professor of Sports Administration at OU. “But the truth is that we aren’t going to be like Boise State or Utah for a very long time. We don’t have the resources.”

Such schools have the advantage of boasting one of the few major athletic programs in their geographic region, which allows them to capture all of the advertising revenue and recruiting options available. Schools such as Ohio that compete in the same region as many other major-market universities cannot do this.

“The sun will rise in the West before we go to a Rose Bowl,” Vedder said. “Measuring efficiency this way doesn’t take into consideration that appearing in the ‘Bowl of Last Resort’ isn’t equal in any way to appearing in a BCS game.”

Read more here: http://thepost.ohiou.edu/Main.asp?SectionID=2&SubSectionID=4&ArticleID=32148
Copyright 2026