Aug. 28 was the forty-seventh anniversary of the day the Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King gave his famous “I Have a Dream” speech on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial. The speech marked the climax of the civil rights march on Washington and is one of the most eloquent, impassioned and beloved speeches in American history.
The men and women who stood on the capitol grounds and heard his words had endured great hardships to be there. They had suffered harassment and intimidation along the way, often at the hands of state governments, and many had risked arrest or worse just by going on the march. To say it was an iconic moment in American history is an understatement.
Dr. King had for months been preaching a message of peaceful, non-violent resistance in the face of extreme injustice. This was not a message for cowards – the non-violent resister does, in fact, resist, as King said. He does so by not being physically violent or confrontational toward his opponent. As he wrote in his essay “Nonviolence and Racial Justice” in 1957, the non-violent resister is “passive physically but strongly active spiritually” and is convinced that “the universe is on the side of justice.” In the face of extreme evil, the temptation toward retaliatory violence is strong, but the non-violent resister rejects it as self-defeating.
The methods of passive non-violence advocated by King and practiced by the civil rights marchers worked; of this there can be no doubt. When the white police turned dogs and fire hoses on black protesters in Alabama, it did not destroy the movement. Instead, it turned the nation’s eyes collectively toward the racism and oppression of the American South. The actions of the state government at the time only strengthened the movement and brought about the most sweeping social change the country had seen in generations. Non-violence works.
Which brings us to another event that happened this weekend. On Aug. 28 of this year, a young Marine, Staff Sergeant Michael Bock, was laid to rest in Omaha. Attending his funeral, aside from his family, friends and fellow Marines, were several members of the controversial Westboro Baptist Church. They were there with their usual assortment of signs and songs designed to inflame emotions and incite a confrontation from bystanders. Present in silent counter-protest and protecting the church were about two hundred members of the Patriot Guard, a band of motorcycle enthusiasts who attend and provide moral support for the families of the fallen.
Midway through the protest, however, one bystander took it upon himself to engage in more direct action. A man driving past the church fired pepper spray at the WBC protesters. It’s not clear whether or how many of them he hit; they, of course, deny being affected. He did, however, manage to hit a few counter-protesters and innocent bystanders.
Back to non-violence. What the Westboro Baptist Church does is not non-violent protest. It is in every way the opposite. Their signs and songs, as I have said, are designed to inflame and incite, and that is the essence of spiritually violent protest. As tempting as it is to respond in kind, the only way to deal with this kind of protest is by non-violent resistance. Confronting them, whether by verbal or (in this case) physical methods, only emboldens them and gives them a propaganda victory.
By attacking them, our passing motorist (who has since been charged with sixteen counts of misdemeanor assault and one count of felony assault for spraying a police officer) unwittingly made them the victims.
I am not writing this to defend the WBC. Their actions are abhorrent and despicable. They neither need my defense nor deserve it. Can there be anything lower than protesting the funeral of a Marine who died defending your right to protest?
I am instead writing this as a caution to future counter-protesters. You cannot counter violence with more violence. Doing so only emboldens them. Thanks to the misguided actions of one lone motorist, Omaha can now surely expect even more attention from the WBC in the future.
Those who would counter their violence must meet it with peaceful resistance. Take a page from Dr. King’s book and meet violence with peace. Let them do the shouting and screaming. Let them make fools of themselves. Someone has to be the adult; let it be you.