Southern Illinois U. law professor Amos Guiora spoke Monday about defining terrorism and the lack of real strategy the U.S. has in place to prevent attacks.
“There is no strategy,” Guiora said. “We are lurching from event to event hoping to respond effectively because we aren’t good at being proactive.”
Guiora is considered an authority in the field of terrorism and interrogation techniques after publishing several works as well as serving for the Israel Defense Forces. He has spoken in front of Congress twice on the topic of terrorism and now goes to different institutions teaching people about the topic.
Guiora said there are limits to the government’s power in regard to preventing terrorism. He said terrorism has never been defined even though it has become a common word in our everyday language since 9/11.
“Terrorism is an attempt by an individual or group to harm, injure, or kill innocent civilians in order to attract government attention,” Guiora said.
Guiora said it is very difficult for the government to intervene and prevent terrorist attacks because they are often random and leads are not based on reliable information.
“An act of terrorism does not necessarily mean the government was ineffective,” Guiora said. “Some cannot be prevented.”
Guiora also spoke about interrogation techniques and how ineffective torture is in regards to yielding quality information. Detainees often tell interrogators everything they want to hear regardless of whether it is true or not. Guiora has written a book on the subjects of torture and the lack of justice for suspected terrorists.
“Nine years after 9/11, there is no due process of law for individual suspected to be involved in [terrorist attacks],” Guiora said.
Guiora said it is imperative to use moral judgment in regard to interrogating suspected terrorists and do everything we can in order to be proactive against terrorist attacks, even if we will never be able to stop it completely.
“We will never defeat terrorism,” Guiora said. “It is undefeatable.”
Guiora teaches courses on criminal law and counter-terrorism, along with religion and terrorism at the University of Utah S.J. Quinney College of Law. As an Israeli-American and former member of the Israel Defense Forces, Guiora said he feels his history applies directly to his work.
“My career and experiences in the Israeli Defense Forces enabled me to address issues that are of great relevance to America today,” Guiora said. “The fact that I was trained in American law school and taught in American law school allowed me to explain [those issues] from a constitutional perspective.”
Guiora is the author of a number of different publications, including last year’s “Freedom from Religion: Rights and National Security.” In it, he argues curtailing speech from religious extremists must be considered in combating terrorism.
“We combat religious extremism by asking ourselves if we need to limit the free speech of religious leaders,” Guiora said. “If law enforcement has information that a faith leader is engaging in incitement, then it’s legitimate to monitor him and surveil him.”
Guiora is quick to point out the prosecution of religious leaders must not be limited to Islam, providing the example of a Mormon sect that incites its members to marry underage girls.
“It’s not about faith,” Guiora said. “It’s about religious extremism in Christianity, Judaism and Islam.”