All that protein may be going straight to your hips

By Ying Lam

For many gym-goers, chugging a protein shake has become almost second nature — just another part of their workout routine.

But while protein supplements have been touted as a way to improve your physique, their benefits won’t be realized by everyone who tries them.

Whether additional protein intake is a healthy choice for someone depends on their own physical state as well as their personal fitness goals.

The familiar sight of my brother lugging around a huge tub of Muscle Milk powder prompted me to give protein supplements a try myself. After working out, I attempted to scarf down some protein bars: Met-Rx Protein Plus (Chocolate Chunk), EAS Myoplex Lite (Chocolate Chip Crisp) and CLIF Builder’s (Peanut Butter).

They all tasted pretty chalky on the first bite and I couldn’t finish them, so I inspected the wrappers instead. The nutrition labels showed up to 32 grams of protein content, which is really overkill when the average intake ranges from 40-70 grams a day.

And according to Steinhardt nutrition professor Marion Nestle, protein isn’t exactly something that’s lacking in most Americans’ diets to begin with.

“Most people eat twice as much protein as they need,” she said.

There are also far too many extra ingredients in each product; there were nearly 60 in one of the bars. According to Nestle, you should stick to products that contain no more than five ingredients. If the choice is between nearly pure whey protein (the kind of stuff that goes into a good protein shake) and meal bars of questionable substance, go for the whey.

And what about the weight loss appeal of these products? According to Ariele Gordon, R.D., of Cher Nutrition, a diet of protein meal replacement bars is counteractive to weight loss.

“If a person consumes exclusively bars, not only will they be harming their own health by existing on such a hypo-caloric meal plan, but they will slow down their metabolism, making weight loss even more of an obstacle.”

Some students said they purposefully steer clear of meal replacement bars.

“Why replace meals?” NYU sophomore Deb Kim said. “Maybe it’s old fashioned, but eating frequent, small meals daily and eating things in moderation is the best diet in my opinion.”

NYU sophomore Jason Wang said he sees the appeal of protein supplements, but doesn’t use them himself. “Just regular food,” he said.

Read more here: http://nyunews.com/life/2010/08/08/09protein/
Copyright 2026 Washington Square News