Over the past couple of weeks, The Oregonian has been asking its readers to pick an all-decade Oregon State football team. As you can imagine, it’s a tough task. So many notable names come to mind, all of which bring back so many notable memories.
I’m here to try to set the record straight. Just who should be on the OSU all-decade team?
My defensive team selections:
Defensive ends
Nominees: DeLawrence Grant (1999-2000), Bill Swancutt (2001-2004), LaDairis Jackson (1999-2000), Dorian Smith (2006-2007), Victor Butler (2005-2008), Slade Norris (2006-2008).
Wow, I would have liked to have any one of those guys on last year’s defense, which featured a less than impressive pass rush. More than anyone, I would have liked to have Bill Swancutt on that team. The Oregon State all-time leader in sacks was named Pac-10 co-defensive layer of the year as a senior in 2004, so he clearly has a spot on the all-decade team. Grant was a big-name player, but Smith and Butler both earned first-team All-Conference recognition – Grant only earned second team. Hmm. Give me Butler. After all, he now plays for the Cowboys, my second-favorite NFL team.
My pick: Bill Swancutt and Victor Butler
Oregonian readers pick: Swancutt (49%) and Butler (25%)
Defensive tackles
Nominees: Eric Manning Jr. (1999-2002), Dwan Edwards (2000-2003), Sir Henry Anderson (2003-2005), Stephen Paea (2008-present).
Manning Jr. was recognized as a Pac-10 first-teamer twice. Edwards is a big name. Sir Henry Anderson had a cool, easy-to-remember name. And Paea is a human wrecking ball. I’ll take Manning and Paea. I had to pick Paea – I wouldn’t want him mad at me. As I’m sure you’ve heard, the dude can bench press 225 pounds an astonishing 44 times.
My pick: Eric Manning Jr. and Stephen Paea
Oregonian readers pick: Stephen Paea (53%) and Dwan Edwards (30%)
Linebackers
Nominees: Nick Barnett (1999-2002), Richard Seigler (2000-2003), Trent Bray (2002-2005), Keith Ellison (2004-2005), Derrick Doggett (2004-2007), Keaton Kristick (2006-2009).
Linebacker U., shall we call it? Barnett is in his eighth year as the anchor of the Green Bay Packer defense. Seigler partnered up with Barnett to help anchor the 2001 Fiesta Bowl-winning defense. Bray was a first-team All-Conference selection. Ellison is now having a very successful career in the NFL as a member of the Buffalo Bills. Doggett had a knack for big plays (think: pick-six in 2006 Civil War win). And Kristick – well, you all know who he is. Hard choice, eh? You have to go with Barnett and Seigler, who are probably the two biggest names on this list. For the third spot? It’s a toss up, but I’m going to take Ellison. No, make that Kristick. Eh, no. Make that Doggett. Final answer. Can’t go wrong with someone who has a pick-six versus Oregon on their resume, right?
My pick: Nick Barnett, Richard Seigler, Derrick Doggett
Oregonian readers pick: Barnett (33%), Seigler (30%), and Ellison (14%)
Cornerbacks
Nominees: Dennis Weathersby (1999-2002), Aric Williams (2001-2004), Brandon Browner (2003-2004), Brandon Hughes (2005-2008), Keenan Lewis (2005-2008).
Weathersby is a no-brainer. The Oregon State all-time leader in passes broken up (62), and two-time All-Pac-10 first-teamer, was a fan favorite (and opposing quarterback’s nightmare) in Corvallis. Unfortunately, Weathersby turned out to be one of the sadder, more forgotten stories when he took his game to the next level. Just days before the 2002 NFL draft, Weathersby was seriously injured after he was shot when he was mistaken for a gang member. His draft stock fell (he went in the fourth round to Cincinnati), and his injuries took longer to heal than expected. A string of bad luck – more injuries and a 2004 car crash that put him into a coma – prevented Weathersby from reaching his potential at the next level, and eventually led him to retire in 2008. Brandon Browner, the 2004 Pac-10 Freshman of the Year, was one of the more pathetic stories of the decade. After finishing second-team All-Pac-10 as a redshirt sophomore, Browner elected to turn pro. Had he stayed, he just might have become the greatest defensive back in Oregon State history. But he didn’t. And he didn’t exactly succeed at the next level, either. He currently plays in the Canadian Football League. I’m a loyal Beaver, and I like loyalty. So I’m going to leave Browner off my all-decade team. That leaves me to pick between Williams, Hughes, and Lewis. Williams never was a No. 1 corner, so that knocks him out. Hughes and Lewis shared the field for four years together as starters, so it’s hard to pick between the two. In the end, I have to go with Hughes, solely based on the fact that he was named second-team All-Conference twice, whereas Lewis made only one All-Conference team (honorable mention as a senior).
My pick: Dennis Weathersby and Brandon Hughes
Oregonian readers pick: Weathersby (47%) and Browner/Hughes (both 17%)
Safeties
Nominees: Mitch Meeuwsen (2001-2004), Sabby Piscitelli (2003-2006), Al Afalava (2005-2008), Greg Laybourn (2006-2008)
This one is relatively easy. Although Laybourn played an important role in one of the decade’s greatest games (his fourth quarter interception helped seal the 2008 upset over No. 1 USC), and although Afalava might have the most successful NFL career of those nominated (he started for the Chicago Bears as a rookie in 2009), you have to go with Meeuwsen and Piscitelli here. Both safeties notched first-team All-Conference honors as seniors, and both made a habit of picking off opposing quarterbacks. Meeuwsen’s 20 career interceptions rank first all-time at Oregon State, while Piscitelli’s 15 are good enough for second.
My pick: Mitch Meeuwsen and Sabby Piscitelli.
Oregonian readers pick: Piscitelli (43%) and Meeuwsen (38%)
And for good measure …
My coach of the decade: Mike Riley. Duh.
My offensive player of the decade: Mike Hass. Although, Steven Jackson was a stud. And either/both of the Rodgers could surpass Hass as the greatest Beaver in recent memory if they produce All-American worthy seasons this season (and for Quizz, next season as well).
My defensive player of the decade: Bill Swancutt. Even though my heart wants me to pick Weathersby and my brain tells me to pick a linebacker, Swancutt was the only OSU defensive player to be named Pac-10 defensive player of the year, so how could I not pick him?