1. Nick Saban: Nicholas Lou Saban has plenty of “haters” (many of them in Baton Rouge and Miami), but it’s impossible to argue that Saban’s approach to coaching college football isn’t a sure-fire recipe for success.
Players frequently get the boot for not buying into Saban’s rough and tough methodology, which leaves only those that buy into the “team concept.” Simply put, Saban is the best college coach in America.
2. Urban Meyer: The man that admitted to texting recruits at church services lands himself at No. 2 on my list after Saban put a whooping on the Gators in last year’s Southeastern Conference Championship game.
Meyer needs to find his inner peace before he has another conniption fit; exploding at Orlando Sentinel reporter Jeremy Fowler did nothing to prove that Meyer has toned it down.
3. Mark Richt: The dean of the SEC finds himself faced with somewhat of a make-or-break season. It’s not that Georgia has to win an SEC title for Richt to stay in Athens, but the Bulldogs do have to show progress – productivity in a new 3-4 defensive scheme and positive signs from first-year starter at quarterback Aaron Murray would help. If Richt can show that his team has a championship-caliber future in the next year or two, his job will be safe.
4. Houston Nutt: In 2008, the expectations were buried somewhere in the dumpsters behind the Johnson Commons, but Nutt managed a nine-win season. There were top-ten aspirations the next year, but things didn’t exactly work out. It’s difficult to judge Nutt’s teams in the preseason, but when he’s at his best, he’s top tier.
5. Bobby Petrino: It’s easy to question his loyalty, but Petrino has done a decent job at both of his collegiate stops. He’s proven he can win big as evidenced by his time at Louisville, but even with a high-flying offense, it will be difficult to dethrone Alabama in the West. Petrino must prove he can win big in this league before moving up in the rankings.
6. Gene Chizik: It wasn’t too long ago when college football prognosticators were tearing apart the Auburn brass for Chizik’s hire. Count me as was one of those doubters; going 5-19 at Iowa State doesn’t exactly scream “sexy hire.” But Chizik won eight games in his first season, and he’s proven to be an ace recruiter – quickly gathering the top-flight talent necessary to make Auburn’s spread-option attack fully operational.
7. Steve Spurrier: These rankings are based on recent success, so Spurrier would obviously be ranked much higher if this were, say, ten years ago. Spurrier’s last two stops have been with the Washington Redskins (dud) and the Gamecocks, where he’s had trouble replicating the offensive success he had at Florida. The ‘Ole Ball Coach should hang up the visor if he can’t win this year with a stacked team in Columbia.
8. Les Miles: It’s a “what you’ve done for me lately” kind of league, and Miles has failed that test as of late. Miles’ most recent snafu was an ultra-embarrassing display of clock management futility in the final seconds of a loss to Ole Miss. “The Hat” later refuted claims that he had told quarterback Jordan Jefferson to spike the ball with only one second left. Video evidence clearly showed otherwise. Another season of mediocrity and Miles is geauxing out the door.
9. Dan Mullen: In his first year as the Bulldogs’ coach, Dan Mullen won five games, good enough for fourth in the SEC West. Mullen’s biggest win was against Ole Miss, and his next best triumphs were over Kentucky and Vanderbilt. Sure, there were close calls against LSU and Houston, but Ed Orgeron had plenty of those. Please, someone tell me who pushed Nick Saban off of Bryant-Denny and made this guy king.
10. Joker Phillips: Not only does Phillips have the best name in the SEC, he also appears to have a bright future in the league. While recently retired coach Rich Brooks led Kentucky out of the conference’s doldrums, Phillips was the architect as recruiting coordinator, helping to sign blue-chip talent such as Randall Cobb, Derrick Locke and Morgan Newton.
11. Derek Dooley: It’s been the difference between a stripper and a saint in Knoxville. With Lane Kiffin off to college football purgatory at probation-stricken Southern California, first-year coach Derek Dooley is charged with damage control. A recent battle royale involving several Volunteer football players at a local bar wasn’t exactly a great start to the Dooley era.
12. Robbie Caldwell: Bobby Johnson’s surprising departure means Robbie Caldwell is the man at Vandy. What do we know about Caldwell? He’s not related to Indianapolis Colts coach Jim Caldwell, he used to work on a farm where he artificially inseminated turkeys and finally, he’s going to have one heck of a time squeezing more production out of the lowly ‘Dores than Johnson.