At the end of each quarter, without fail, final exam fever sweeps across UCLA’s coffee shops and study nooks, and ordinary students transform into a new breed of caffeine-fueled, textbook-toting creatures.
But while final exams have been a longtime collegiate tradition, at UCLA and nationwide, their effectiveness as tools of evaluation have recently become a topic of debate within academia.
In fact, in the last year, only 23 percent of undergraduate courses at Harvard University required final exams, and a new Harvard curriculum encourages professors to adopt creative final exam alternatives.
Epitomizing this drive toward creative final assessments, one Harvard class required students to write a love poem or narrative epic based on Persian or Arabic examples to demonstrate their knowledge of the arts in Muslim culture.
However, though Harvard may be phasing out final exams, UCLA students shouldn’t throw away their blue books just yet.
While UCLA professors may opt to use other evaluative methods, such as term papers, oral examinations or take-home tests, the majority of undergraduate professors still hold final exams, according to Anita Cotter, UCLA registrar.
This tendency toward final exams is welcomed by many students, who think finals are an effective means of evaluating student mastery of course material.
“Depending on how the test is formatted, I think finals can be effective,” said Anna Miller, a third-year economics/international area studies student. “I learn so much while studying for finals.”
To some though, the tendency of students to study last-minute for final exams can actually be harmful to the learning process.
“With final exams, you are just memorizing and then regurgitating information,” said Jamie Pet, a fifth-year international development studies and Spanish student.
“Through this process, students just learn the bare minimum in order to pass the exam, which can be detrimental to their overall knowledge,” she added.
In contrast, term papers give students the opportunity to critically analyze the course material, such that the knowledge will stick with them for a long time, she said.
These conflicting perspectives regarding the value of various evaluative measures are reflected within the UCLA Academic Senate regulations on final exams.
According to the regulations, professors have the freedom to propose a range of evaluative methods, which must then gain approval by the curriculum committee of the undergraduate council, or the appropriate faculty committee.
Though evaluation methods may vary from class to class, they must adequately reflect student achievement, according to the regulations. Additionally, the method of evaluation must be announced by professors at the beginning of a course.
“There is no single type of evaluative tool that works across all levels and courses,” said Robin Garrell, chair of the UCLA Academic Senate and professor of chemistry and biochemistry. “The evaluative tool that is used depends on the material of the course and the students’ level.”
Thus, while final exams may be appropriate in some courses, other measures may be more applicable for others.
And to some members of the UCLA community, it is the ends, rather than the means, that is important.
According to Corey Hollis, director of College Academic Counseling, “The most important factor is that students demonstrate their mastery of course material, whether through final exams, or other methods.”