In the courts of Salem, Mass., 20 people were sentenced to death under witchcraft charges. About 200 more were suspects subject to erroneous investigations and trials. The invasion of privacy and neglect of constitutional rights made Salem a terrifying place to be in the 17th century. Now, the immigration controversy has turned a new, but similar leaf. We have created a witch hunt this century in our hunt for illegal immigrants.
Fast forward to present-day Salt Lake City, to the release of a list accusing 1,300 people of being illegal immigrants. Because the list includes addresses, phone numbers and Social Security numbers, it is believed to have been created by those who have access to confidential government records. At least two individuals suspected are employees of the Department of Workforce Services.
The list seems to be based off of Hispanic-sounding surnames. This is yet another reason to examine those involved in creating the list, which is beginning to sound more like a hate crime than a concern for the well-being of our nation.
Luciano Marzulli, a coordinator for the Center for Ethnic Student Affairs, said the list wrongly characterizes immigration as an issue only relevant to the Latino community.
As for the effect on students, Marzulli said, “The list, coupled with recently passed anti-immigrant legislation, is emotionally and psychologically damaging to undocumented students and students of color. It sends a message that people of color are not valued by our society.”
To accuse 1,300 people of living here illegally, anonymously and without substantial cause, is not so different from the tragedy in Salem. It has threatened to separate families and terrified the Latino community. Controlling our borders effectively is important, but allowing vigilantes to violate the Constitution and invade the privacy of Utahns is primeval.
The Fourth Amendment prohibits unreasonable search and seizure of persons, which includes paperwork and information. The Fifth Amendment says, “No person shall be…deprived of life, liberty or property without the due process of law,” and the Sixth Amendment ensures a speedy trial by an impartial jury.
The truth is that this violation of privacy affects more than the Hispanic community. If this list is permitted to be used for investigation by law enforcement, it will be an affront to the rights we all are granted. Such breaches of justice, regardless of ethnicity, create new acceptable procedures for the course of justice. If we cannot learn to protect the minority’s rights, then we will fail to protect the majority’s rights as well.