Many U. Iowa students remember their first time signing an apartment lease. The combination of excitement and trepidation one feels while combing the small print in a rental contract for the first time is hard to forget. Putting the pen to the dotted line on the lease is often the first important signature in a student’s life. In Cedar Rapids, the process will soon have a third party involved: the City Council.
The DI Editorial Board would welcome certain steps from the Iowa City City Council if it ever decided to try to curb crime in apartment buildings, but we hope that the council does not follow its neighbor’s example in mandating that apartment owners put a crime-free addendum on their leases.
The DI Editorial Board feels that such an addendum could be a valuable tool for landlords in evicting problematic tenants, but any program in place should be voluntary.
The Cedar Rapids City Council approved the proposal 8-1 at its meeting on July 13, to change a section of its housing code. If the changes go into effect, landlords will be required to stipulate in rental agreements that the tenant will be evicted if he or she commits certain crimes. In addition, landlords whose tenants are involved in criminal activities could lose their licenses to rent units. The specific types of crimes are not stipulated, and the landlord would play the largest role in deciding what criminal activity will be cause for an eviction. Two groups in Cedar Rapids, Landlords of Linn County and Flood-Impacted Landlords, have already asked the City Council to forgo the change in the housing code that would implement the new regulations.
“The goal of the crime-free addendum is to assist the neighborhoods and landlords as they rent to people,” City Councilor Chuck Swore told The Daily Iowan. He noted that in Davenport, where the addendum is voluntary, the majority of landlords use it in their leases. If a voluntary program has been successful in Davenport, a mandate is not necessary in Cedar Rapids or Iowa City. The Cedar Rapids City Council should be applauded for wanting to provide the crime-free addendum as a resource, but forcing its use across the city is overstepping the council’s bounds. The DI Editorial Board would welcome steps taken by the Iowa City City Council to help landlords make their buildings safer, but only by providing the tools, not by inserting provisions into private contracts.
The Cedar Rapids City Council did research on similar programs in cities throughout the Midwest and decided to go with a mandatory ordinance to make it easier to get rid of problematic landlords who did not want to cooperate. But such an ordinance could also pose a danger to tenants’ rights and cause unfair evictions. Swore says that under the program in Cedar Rapids, it will primarily be up to the landlords to determine which crimes are worthy of an eviction. This creates a potential for tenants to misunderstand ambiguous language in apartment leases, which may already be long and complicated. Also, if landlords are worried about losing their licenses because of too much crime in their buildings, a mandatory crime-free addendum could lead to arbitrary evictions.
“I might sign a lease with a provision like that, but I don’t agree with it,” UI student Wade Vander Wilt told the DI Editorial Board as he prepared to walk from his workplace to his apartment on Washington Street. “It’s hard enough finding a place to live. Getting evicted, no-questions-asked, for committing a crime seems heartless.”
The proposal will also expand the Cedar Rapids Police Department’s community volunteer corps and use it to provide background checks to landlords at no cost. Instituting a program for free background checks through the Iowa City Police Department would be an excellent idea, and similar programs have been implemented elsewhere with great success. In Davenport, the background checks have been very useful to the police in clearing up outstanding warrants.
Swore emphasizes that the legislation in Cedar Rapids will change based on how effective the provisions are, saying “as we see what isn’t needed, we’ll get rid of it.” Perhaps the terms of the ordinance in Cedar Rapids will change, and the Iowa City City Council should observe how effective the addendum and background checks are in Cedar Rapids and possibly consider implementing a similar program here. Providing the tools to landlords to make buildings safer is an admirable goal, but if Iowa City ever wanted to introduce such a program, it should not intrude on the relationship between landlord and tenant.