As budget cuts simultaneously hurt the quality of education while increasing its cost, it is only natural that stakeholders seek to find where reductions in expense can be effected. One such effort was Chancellor Robert Birgeneau’s Committee on Intercollegiate Athletics. The blue ribbon panel, composed of four alumni and four faculty members, was charged with proposing changes to the funding mechanism for Cal Athletics. In 2008-09 alone, UC Berkeley allocated over $13 million to the department, most of which does not have to be repaid.
The Advisory Council recommended, among other things, that campus support to the department be reduced to $5 million by 2014. While this number looks somewhat arbitrary, it is a good compromise. Clearly, the current level of funding directed towards Intercollegiate Athletics is unsustainable. At the same time, intercollegiate competition tremendously enriches the lives of student-athletes, so some level of campus support is justified.
Unfortunately, the council’s recommendations on how to get to the goal are less than solid. While increases in fundraising would be most welcome, we question how much donors are willing to give in this economy. Even less realistic is the proposal for our campus to lead a national campaign against the athletics “arms race” of recent decades.
We fear the real solution may be the elimination of some teams, something that happens to be a great incentive for belt-tightening. If team cuts are unavoidable, it makes the most sense to cut the teams that lose the most money per athlete. After all, the mission of Intercollegiate Athletics ought to be to provide a high-quality scholar-athlete experience to as many students as possible. The reality is that teams that take a disproportionate cut of the pie are less than conducive to this mission.
At the same time, we warn against overly broad cuts to the revenue-generating sports. Coaching salaries, among other expenses, do seem extreme. However, a large cutback in funding would hurt competitive quality. In turn, this would reduce revenue and alumni donations, diminishing the amount of money available for non-revenue sports. We do not mean to say that expense reductions in football and men’s basketball cannot help in bridging the budget gap but rather we urge caution in how these cuts are made.
The chancellor wields tremendous power in this situation. He will be pressured by those who oppose campus allocations to Cal Athletics and by those who oppose cuts. While it may be difficult to hew to a middle course, we hope he recognizes that, in this case, the middle course is the correct one.