Column: Different books for different personalities

By Jennifer DuBose

I, the “let’s-spread-the-joy-of-reading” English major, thought it would be possible to recommend a book for every personality type, until I did some research.  Quickly, I was humbled as I read about dozens of personality theories and models and realized that I have not the authority or the psychological knowledge to make this article satisfy every reader.  Most people share traits from two or more personality types, making it impossible to declare a book perfect for one type and ill-fitting for another.  Amid my dismay and confusion, with diagrams of Jungians, Doshas, and Somatotypes biting at my sense of self, I decided to settle with “The Four Humors” theory.  Because this was the first personality model, developed by the ancient Greeks, and because both William Shakespeare and Geoffrey Chaucer used it for characterization and poetic flow, it proves adequate enough for me.

The first humor is a “choleric” one, meaning that the person this describes is often irritable because of an excess of yellow bile, associated with fire.  So, what would someone with a liver full of yellow bile want to read?  I recommend a book that addresses social problems and human rights, like The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood.  The book moves reasonably fast with chilling scenarios and uncensored conflicts both internal and external. In the novel, women are banned from reading or learning and are assigned to positions in society based on the condition of their ovaries and looks.  This is a novel sure to evoke further analysis of society, along with nightmares.

The “melancholic” humor results from an excess of black bile, and often is assigned to the pessimistic type.  For this, I suggest Catch-22 by Joseph Heller.  What melancholy individual would not enjoy a book whose title denotes a lose-lose situation?  A satirical historical novel set in the late stages of World War II, Catch-22 offers a healthy mix of dark humor and gory battle scenes.  It is difficult to summarize the book because it is written in a non-chronological style which mirrors the confusion and craziness of the world. The book reveals the brutal and unforgiving nature of war and life in general.

On a brighter note, the “sanguine” humor, having an excess of blood, is the personality type of the optimistic and open-minded.  Weetzie Bat by Francesca Lia Block is perfect for the sanguine.  The story takes place in a romanticized Los Angeles, named Shangri-LA, featuring characters Weetzie and Dirk.  Weetzie is granted three wishes by a genie and experiences their unexpected ramifications. While being almost a fairytale, the book freely explores the issues of blended families, AIDS and homosexuality. The book, which continues to be a bestseller, was published in 1989 and birthed a completely new genre called Pop-Magic-Realism.

The last humor is “phlegmatic”, the excess liquid being phlegm, and applies to calm and passive folk.  The Diaries of Adam and Eve by Mark Twain is a beautiful spin on the classic Bible story and reflects Twain’s easy-going style.  Written as a series of diary entries, the book provides fictional viewpoints from both Adam and Eve, and gives such details as their first impressions of the stars, each other and God as they grow and mature together in and out of Eden.  Christians and non-Christians alike will find this book to be enjoyable as it projects an original love story and humanistic values.

Read more here: http://www.thebatt.com/features/different-books-for-different-personalities-1.1499788
Copyright 2026 The Battalion