State official: City’s PAULA ratio flawed

By Alex Kline

Iowa City’s PAULA-to-police-visit ratio may no longer be as significant for those seeking liquor-license renewals.

Iowa Alcoholic Beverages Division Administrator Stephen Larson ruled on Tuesday that the city’s controversial regulation does not comply with state code, and he ordered the reversal of the City Council’s decision to deny the renewal of the liquor license for 3rd Base, 111 E. College St.

In his order, he noted the definition of a “police visit” is unclear and that the ratio did not make clear if the person charged with a PAULA had consumed alcohol in the bar.

3rd Base, also known as the Fieldhouse, and Et Cetera, which has since closed, were the first two bars whose liquor-license renewals were denied by the council under the new rule. Both appealed to the state, and Administrative Law Judge Margaret LaMarche sided with the bars in December 2009.

The city appealed on Jan. 6, sending the decision to Larson, who took over as alcohol administrator May 1.

“The city’s reliance on [the PAULA ratio] to deny the renewal application based solely on the PAULA citation statistics presented at hearing is inconsistent with … the rules of the Division defining ‘good moral character,’ ” Larson wrote.

The City Council has 30 days to appeal Larson’s decision. Assistant City Attorney Eric Goers, who has represented the city throughout the process, said the council will discuss the matter in an executive session at its next meeting Aug. 16.

If the city appeals, it will go to district court. If the council decides not to appeal, or appeals and loses, the ratio could still be kept, but a ratio exceeding 1 per visit will not automatically mean a denial.

Saying he is not surprised at the decision, Mayor Matt Hayek said the need for a PAULA policy depends on whether the 21 ordinance is upheld in November.

“Meaning if we keep the 21-ordinance, with respect to the referendum, you could make the argument that the PAULA policy is no longer needed,” he said.

But Councilor Connie Champion said she hopes the council will decide to pursue an appeal.

“[The ruling] is a big problem, because we don’t have any way to control liquor licenses,” she said.

In his order, Larson said the PAULA ratio can show a bar doesn’t have “good moral character” — a quality the state uses to decide on a liquor-license denial — but it is not enough in itself.

“A large number of PAULA citations issued to patrons inside a licensed establishment may constitute a ‘pattern and practice’ of violations governing the license,” the report said.

However, the report stated the city wrongly applied the ratio rule to the owner and employees of 3rd Base because it did not prove they had ignored or knew about underage drinking in the establishment.

Larson’s report also stated the circumstances revolving around the PAULA citations and the definition of a police “visit” were unclear.

And with a lack of officer testimony, he said, “the city revealed nothing about the circumstances surrounding the issuance of the 143 PAULA citations” in 3rd Base.

Larson said it was not clear if the people charged with PAULA were “merely holding or actually consuming alcohol” or if they presented a fake ID at the door or to the officer.

Despite being a newly appointed administrator, Larson told The Daily Iowan it was not difficult to make the decision and declined to comment further.


Read more here: http://www.dailyiowan.com/2010/07/21/Metro/18064.html
Copyright 2026 The Daily Iowan