University will not denounce research

By Megan Rogers

The Responsible Drilling Alliance (RDA) has asked Penn State to denounce research done by Penn State professors on the Marcellus Shale natural gas deposit, but university officials said they have no plans to do so.

In early June, the alliance, which strives to understand the issues raised by natural gas drilling, sent a letter to Penn State President Graham Spanier and William Easterling, dean of the College of Earth and Mineral Sciences. The letter asked Penn State to denounce research on the economic impact of Marcellus Shale.

The research — which was conducted by Penn State professors Seth Blumsack and Robert Watson and retired Penn State professor Tim Considine — determined that in 10 years, the Marcellus Shale resource could create 200,000 new jobs and increase gains in state and local tax revenue by more than a billion dollars.

The alliance wants the university to denounce the findings, but it is not university policy to take a position on any of its faculty research, university spokesman Geoff Rushton said.

Though the Marcellus Shale Coalition funded the study, the report had a disclaimer at the beginning so readers could be aware of who was funding the research, Rushton said.

A big part of the university mission is promoting research and discovery — and conclusions are a natural part of that scientific process, Rushton said. There are always going to be those who disagree with the researcher’s findings but it is important that the university maintains its role as a “safe haven” for researchers to explore complex issues like Marcellus Shale, he said.

Critics can debate the study’s conclusions, but the Penn State researchers are within the bounds of economic analysis, he said.

Rushton said the study has been examined by experts and it has been determined that the research was on solid ground scientifically.

Considine said he was “vaguely” aware of the letter the RDA sent to the university, but he said his team’s research is well regarded.

“We stand by the research,” he said. “Penn State can do whatever they want as far as I’m concerned.”

Rushton said the university will abide by its policy and not take a position on the research. The only “position” the university has is that they are dedicated to helping the state develop what Rushton calls a “unique opportunity” by providing the best scientific information available.

The RDA did not respond to requests for comment by press time Wednesday.

Read more here: http://www.collegian.psu.edu/archive/2010/07/15/university_will_not_denounce_r.aspx
Copyright 2026 Daily Collegian