Column: Utah should put an age restriction on fireworks, not ban them

By Alex Noshirvan

When I think of July, grilling, drinking and blowing things up are the first thoughts that run through my head. But here in Utah, the blowing stuff up part mostly consists of sparklers, ground flowers or fountains—in other words, nothing is getting blown up.

Yet just 80 miles away, the residents in Wyoming get all the primo stuff they can handle, such as bottle rockets, Roman candles and mortars. If these fireworks are so unsafe, then why are they allowed in Wyoming, and why can’t Utah put an age restriction on buying these fireworks as a way to regulate them?

My guess is that our Legislature wants to preemptively strike down fireworks—just like everything else in this state that is deemed “unsafe,” such as alcohol, tobacco and medical marijuana.

“It’s not ideal, but it’s what we are left to work with,” said Jace Monsen, an employee at the fireworks tent on the 800 South and 900 East Smith’s parking lot. “Sure, we would love to be able to sell bottle rockets and that kind of stuff, but we make do with what we have.”

We don’t read about Wyoming residents dying left and right from their firework use, nor does it seem like they have a higher rash of auto fatalities from drivers drinking a stronger beer than us. In fact, Utah had 245 auto fatalities compared to 134 in Wyoming in 2009, and that isn’t compared in per-capita terms. In per-capita terms, Wyoming does outpace Utah—but we all know it’s a commuter state.

In the same way, it seems to me that states such as California and Colorado seem to be doing just fine with the medical marijuana laws that they have in place.

So once again, Utah is living up to its nanny state reputation. It’s a shame, because this state’s stunning visual beauty is often overshadowed by its zany rules.

Let people be responsible for their actions. If you are dumb enough to lose a limb to a firecracker, then it is your own fault. Like Forrest Gump found out on his cross-country run, stuff happens.

In 1976, Americans bought 29 million pounds of fireworks. In 2007, that number ballooned to 265.5 million pounds, according to the trade association American Pyrotechnics Association. Although the rate of buying fireworks has gone up 920 percent, there has been a 90 percent decrease in firework-related injuries per 100,000 pounds in that same time.

We’ve all seen those posters warning us about the dangers of fireworks. We get it. Fireworks are dangerous. But so are cars. If you treat them with respect and responsibility, the chances of getting hurt are drastically reduced.

A 2008 report on firework injuries by the Consumer Product Safety Commission showed that children under 15 accounted for 40 percent of all firework-related injuries.

Kids that young should not be playing with anything firework related except for sparklers and pop-its. They can still experience fireworks, just with the safety of parent or adult supervision. Too often we have lax parenting that results in horrific injuries to kids.

These injuries will be snapped up by newspapers and television news outlets and played up to be the most dangerous thing that will affect your kids during the summer. In all actuality, poor parenting is the more pressing issue.

My solution is to limit the higher-powered fireworks to adults 21 and over. By doing this, we limit legal responsibilities to adults only. If a kid gets hurt playing with an illegal firework, then it’s his fault. Not the state’s, not the fire department’s and not the fireworks’ fault.

But I’m a realist and as such I’m resigned to the fact that we probably will not get firework reform. So enjoy those sparklers, Pop-Its, snakes and ground flowers—it’s all we can legally do.

Read more here: http://www.dailyutahchronicle.com/opinion/utah-should-put-an-age-restriction-on-fireworks-not-ban-them-1.2279662
Copyright 2026 Daily Utah Chronicle