Column: Cut the clucking in City Council – let Evanston have its hens

By Michael Carson

Living in America offers a certain kind of freedom.

If I want to sit on my porch and leaf through Playboy while I clean my handgun and recite the Old Testament, it’s my constitutionally protected right to do so. Come to think of it, in parts of America it might get me elected to Congress.

It always seemed to me that one of the best things about this country is that on the confines of my property, I can do mostly as I please without the government meddling in my business. That’s why, as I write this column, I am participating in the democratic process and raising my voice in support of freedom. As of three minutes ago, I am Signer #153 of the online Petition to Allow Backyard Chickens in Evanston.

Turns out backyard chickens are something of a fad with the granola set, with support for the legalization of residential chicken coops cropping up in cities across the country. Last year the trend grew big enough to reach the zenith of any real craze: an article in the New Yorker, detailing the daily joys and pains of raising hens in a mass-produced, pastel-colored $650 plastic chicken coop called an “Eglu.” And to think some folks settle for shopping at Whole Foods.

Last Wednesday, the Evanston proposal to legalize backyard hens deadlocked with a 2-2 vote in committee, and it will be another month before anyone knows if the proposal will make it in front of the entire Evanston city council.

I don’t make a habit of going around signing petitions, but this issue is near to my heart. You see, I knew about backyard chickens long before they were cool. And I think it’s high time the City Hall bigwigs stepped aside and returned our God-given right to poultry.

My grandparents lived in the west suburb of Bensenville for the better part of the last 60 years. Today the streets are dotted with the usual suburban homes, but when my grandfather finished his house there in the 1958, his property was on unincorporated land outside a little town by the airport, where almost 30% of the 10,000 residents were first or second generation immigrants.

My grandparents chased the American Dream like any pair of hardworking people who could still remember the Old Country. My grandpa worked all week as a carpenter, then came home on Sundays to work some more on his house. Over time he built a home, raised a family inside of it, and eventually put up a chicken coop in the back. Not that they stopped at chickens—my relatives tell stories of days when my grandpa had dogs, sheep, chickens, goats, pheasants, beehives and a few fully grown male peacocks.

It’s not like they were the block hillbillies—other neighbors raised chickens the same way. One of my mother’s favorite pets was a baby chick she found in the street, a hen she called Sydney until one night when my Yiayia called it dinner. Eventually she got over it.

The kind of amateur farming that the Evanston Backyard Chicken Committee has in mind looks a little different than what I remember about my grandfather and his lopsided old henhouse—for starters, I think if he were still alive the idea of a $650 chicken coop would’ve left him shaking his head and muttering in Greek.

In the ’90s, after the rest of the neighborhood had been developed, some neighbor finally got tired of 5 a.m. rooster calls and took my grandparents to the village board to try to get them to tear down the chicken coop. The old man—a bit wiser, a touch grayer, the recent beneficiary of an open heart surgery—fought like one of his roosters backed into a corner. It was his property, and this was America, and no son-of-a-beech would tell him to get rid of his henhouse. He kept the chickens.

My Papou passed away the day before my high school graduation. I don’t know any of the Evanston Backyard Chicken Committee, but most “urban poultry” types I’ve read about don’t remind me much of that proud old guy who wouldn’t let anyone tell him what to do in his own backyard. But I still believe the Evanston folks want what my grandparents always intuitively had—a common-sense kind of self-reliance and a feeling of real ownership over their own property.

I want those things too someday, once I can start thinking seriously about a job, a family, a house and a dream of my own. Who knows, maybe with a little backyard chicken coop, to remind me of all I’ve got.

Read more here: http://www.dailynorthwestern.com/carson-cut-the-clucking-in-city-council-let-evanston-have-its-hens-1.2280230
Copyright 2026 Daily Northwestern