Column: U. Kansas needs more nuanced approach to study abroad

By Stephen Montemayor

I find myself regretting not traveling abroad for a semester or more as I come to grips with my extra time in the Free State.

Had I elected to spend a summer honing the Spanish I must now perfect post-graduation, Puebla, Mexico would have been a potential, if not likely, destination. It is the site of the University’s Summer Language Institute and is located in central Mexico, about 70 miles from Mexico City.

Eighteen students were to study there this summer, but a Department of State travel warning specific to the country’s northern border states necessitated other plans per University policy.

I spoke to Sue Lorenz, director of the Office of Study Abroad about the influence of drug-related violence on study abroad programs. She said that because the advisory was issued in March — and later reissued April 12 — the office was afforded enough time for alternate plans. As a result, 15 of the 18 students agreed to relocate their studies to Costa Rica.

All this despite the fact that Puebla is located hundreds of miles and several hours away from the thickest areas of drug-related contention. Yet this matters not as University policy dictates that students may not be sent by the college to any country with a travel warning, regardless of the specifics of the advisory.

“What we’re just seeing is a straight up cautious policy,” Lorenz said. “Here we can be sure we have not sent students where the place is volatile. The University is saying we’re using our best and broadest judgment.”

The University is not alone in adopting such policies and caution must be exercised in critiquing measures taken for safety reasons. Still, this blanket policy begs the question of whether a more nuanced approach to interpreting travel advisories can be taken. It can.

Even the most selective consumers of news are aware of the grisly nature of drug-related violence in Mexico and around the U.S.-Mexico border. One or more reports of beheadings, daylight firefights or assassinations arrive each week. The situation in areas of cartel influence is indeed dire.

This is not to say that the country as a whole is impassable. Those studying in Costa Rica this summer will need to exercise the same caution that would have been recommended in Puebla. Furthermore, we too often take for granted that just as many locations in our own country require as much or more caution.

Bypassing a country like Mexico because a travel advisory is in effect stokes the possibility for emerging stereotypes. Mexico is a beautiful land with vast cultural opportunities. Its beauty, however, is often overshadowed by the drug war and immigration debate.

The University would do well by adopting the response procedures to travel warnings as suggested by the National Association of Foreign Student Advisors, or NAFSA.

A report outlining eight suggested guidelines was published on NAFSA’s website on March 22.

It suggests a variety of stakeholders at the institution be involved in reviewing the warning, contacting relevant partners abroad to gauge what risks are of concern, establishing emergency response plans and comparing activities and program locations to the areas mentioned in the travel advisory.

Though this could easily be met with ignorance and generalities about the state of affairs in Mexico, it bears repeating that it is indeed possible to be too cautious.

We stand to lose a great deal in a world of opportunity if we do not take risks. A more nuanced approach to travel advisories would mean that the risks study-abroad participants and the University take would be calculated and, ultimately, rewarded.

Read more here: http://www.kansan.com/news/2010/jul/13/montemayor-ku-needs-more-nuanced-approach-study-ab/
Copyright 2026 University Daily Kansan